Giles Fraser writes:
These are good: Vladimir Putin. White identity politics.
Star Wars. Austrian free market economics. Donald Trump. LOLs. Bitcoin. Darwinism.
Silicon Valley. Science and technology. Transhumanism. Pepe the Frog.
These are bad: Islam. Feminism.
Democracy. Black Lives Matter. The new Ghostbusters movie. Egalitarianism.
Political correctness. God. Immigration. Hillary Clinton. Newspapers.
Government. Academia. Liberalism.
Welcome to the complicated world
of the so-called alternative (or alt) right. Think Mein Kampf meets The
Big Bang Theory.
For years these socially dysfunctional millennials
have sheltered behind their bedroom laptops, watching porn, sending abusive
tweets (anonymously) and eating pizza in their underpants.
Mainstream politics
– both left and right – has previously ignored this developing phenomenon.
But
with Donald Trump they have found a champion who understands their anger. And
they have become his digital vanguard.
Tonight in Nevada, Hilary Clinton will
give a major speech linking Trump to the alt right. And with this speech
the alt right will further enter the political mainstream.
One account of their rise to
political significance cites the
2014 Gamergate controversy.
This vicious internet culture war took
place between those who were pressing for a more inclusive video gaming culture
(more women, less violence) and those who reacted against what they saw as a
humourless leftwing threat to their
enjoyment of guns and boobs.
These burgeoning alt right gamers have
little in common with traditional Republican conservatives and their
evangelical Christian values.
They don’t go to church. Indeed, many are
aggressively atheistic.
Rather, they come together on blogs and online community
forums like 4chan where they fulminate against social justice warriors – SJWs –
who want to spoil their fun.
They hate the liberal apparatus of the state,
including the mainstream press and Ivy League academia that they collectively
dub as The Cathedral.
And they hate normies – normal people – and their
repressive political philosophy, democracy.
Instead of democracy, they propose
that the US should be run like a large company with a CEO at its head,
preferably one from Silicon Valley.
Someone like PayPal founder Peter Thiel,
whose views include: “I
no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible.”
But
Trump will do for now.
Oh, and only intelligent people should be in charge, and
that means white people.
“Ever since Mill wrote his
response to Carlyle on The Negro Question, writers of the English Protestant
tradition have been defending the blatantly theological position that ‘all men
are created equal’,” wrote the
computer programmer and alt-right hero Curtis Yarvin under his pen name Mencius Moldbug.
He
continued: “Note that exactly the same rhetorical strategy can prove the
existence of God or the Flying Spaghetti Monster for that matter.”
Traditional Republicans are now regularly dismissed by
the revolting term cuckservatives – an insult first used by white supremacists
of Christian conservatives who, they said, have allowed themselves to be
cuckolded by racial minorities.
They darkly summon the idea of interracial sex
– a theme that was also an obsessive preoccupation of the KKK.
And its meaning
broadens out to refer to those who witness their country being taken away and
don’t have the balls to do anything to stop it.
That’s why they want a US
version of Putin. Because they don’t think he would allow that to happen.
Of course, racism has a long and
inglorious history in US politics.
But it now has a very new
iteration in the nerdy tech-savvy generation of the alt right. Racism 2.0.
They
don’t speak of eugenics but rather of maintaining “human biodiversity”. And
they have a thing about IQ tests showing that white people are cleverer than
others.
I know, we’ve heard all this crap
many times before. But there is something new here.
For in cross-pollinating with
the anonymity and viciousness of the internet, with porn and video games
replacing Christianity as
the common language in which conservatives talk to each other, with openly
anti-democratic impulses being justified as rationality, the virus of racism is
capable of spreading as never before.
The age of the Christian right
is over.
And something worse is set to take its place.
A caricature, don't you think?
ReplyDeleteAdmittedly the Alt-Right are indeed racists, so they cannot be supported, but many of the pathologies they are reacting to are real.
And isn't Giles Fraser one of those Christians who will always put progressive ideology before his religion? The ones who would be unrecognisable to past generations of Christians?
No.
DeleteYou are thinking, if anything, of the doctrine-light but socially conformist C of E of the 1950s.
Giles Fraser's article sums up why Trump has happened.
ReplyDeleteThe absence of any conservative patriotic formation in American politics that is neither racist nor liberal and politically correct like Giles Fraser.
As Peter Hitchens says, the absence of political conservatism has created a vacuum for demagogues.
It's not as if he's going to win.
Delete