Rishi Sunak was never the worst, and a bit more on parliamentary oversight could almost make him Tony Benn here:
One thing that Andy Burnham should do in his ten-year plan is give himself more power. He should concentrate on speeding up our sclerotic system of government, removing the obstacles to action. This is where he should be radical and prepared to break with New Labour shibboleths. It isn’t healthy for democracy when governments of all stripes find it so hard to deliver what they have promised; it makes voters cynical and dissatisfied.
Britain used to be criticised for being an elective dictatorship. Yet when you are prime minister, you don’t feel like much of a dictator. You are constantly told of the need to consult on this and the risk of judicial review on that, or that the decision actually rests with some quango. Even Sir Keir Starmer, a human rights lawyer, complained that “every time I go to pull a lever there are a whole bunch of regulations, consultations, arm’s-length bodies” in the way.
This is a rare moment when nearly all parties can see that our system of government needs fixing. Prime ministers having more power isn’t anti-democratic. Indeed, the biggest threat to our democracy is that voters keep voting for change and nothing happens. We have come to fetishise process at the expense of outcomes.
We won’t restore balance until we scrap many of the checks and balances that have accumulated over the past 30 years. Labour ministers, having been out of power for so long, have been surprised by their experience in government. They’ve asked my opinion on procedural changes that, if they had come from me or any other Tory prime minister, they would have denounced as the end of civilisation. Kemi Badenoch, to her credit, has been making the case for change since she first ran to be Tory leader in 2022.
Burnham has made some encouraging noises about taking on the “unaccountable state”. His aim should be a radical transfer of power from unelected and unaccountable bodies to elected and accountable ministers. There are now more than 300 arm’s-length public bodies. Yes, there are some things we don’t want politicians in charge of — such as the Electoral Commission and the Office for National Statistics — but too often quangos remove much-needed democratic accountability. Natural England was able, without explicit parliamentary consent, to issue planning advice which held back the construction of 100,000 homes. When we attempted to overturn it, the House of Lords stopped us. It was an unholy alliance of the unaccountable and the unelected.
The joke that the British government has the engine of a lawnmower and the brakes of a Rolls-Royce has become painfully close to the truth. Too often, rather than making a decision and getting on with it, ministers go out to consultation: about 500 times a year. The government is trying to tackle this, but it needs to go further and faster, removing statutory duties to consult, requirements to conduct impact assessments and the like. This may sound cavalier, but it is for parliament to scrutinise and for elections to act as our error-correction mechanism.
Consultations are often just vehicles for special pleading — more than 70 per cent of the responses to Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms came from visa-holders, not British citizens — and create all sorts of legal traps. One consultation on welfare reform was struck down by the courts, which decided, among other things, that we had not been clear about our motivation. It is madness to have judges trying to open windows into ministers’ souls to work out what they were really thinking.
The bar for a judicial review used to be high. You had to argue that a decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have taken it. But the Human Rights Act changed our legal culture. It introduced a new test of proportionality for anything that touched a convention right. That is far more subjective. The government can lose if it could have used a less intrusive measure to achieve the same result or if the judge simply believes it has not balanced competing interests properly. This approach has now seeped into our common law, leading to a more litigious culture and courts ruling on trade-offs that should be a matter for parliament.
Perhaps the biggest problem, though, with this lower bar for judicial review is the chilling effect it has. The old reasonableness test was so straightforward you didn’t need to be a lawyer to understand it; ministers could act with confidence. But the new grounds are far less clear. I lost count of the number of times I was told, “You can’t do that — you’ll be JR-ed.” Often, if you pushed back, you would find there was a legal way through. Sometimes it just required a different lawyer. But there simply wasn’t time to do that in every case. My other worry: if I was being told this in meetings as prime minister, how many ideas never made it up to my desk because of the perceived risk?
Parliament should legislate to return to the old, higher bar for judicial review. It will require several changes, including scrapping the Human Rights Act — which is why Labour will balk at it. But if we persist with the present system, prime ministers will continue to have to govern with the handbrake on. Legislation created the problem, and legislation can fix it.
The vogue for writing duties and targets into law is a classic illustration of the problem. Things such as the public sector equality duty and wide-ranging employment laws are an invitation to judicial overreach. Legislating for net zero by 2050, rather than simply making a commitment, invites legal challenges to a whole slew of policy-making and requires judges to rule on inherently political choices that should be made by MPs. In 2024 Friends of the Earth won its second case in two years over our climate action plans, and the courts ordered us to rewrite them. Labour will run into the same problem if it tries to change the zero-emissions vehicle mandate. The Climate Change Committee, another quango, is already warning that doing so would put legally binding targets at risk.
The criticism of Britain as an elective dictatorship came from the Conservative politician Lord Hailsham, who was angry that even slim governing majorities gave Labour the authority to make huge changes. But the right response to policies you disagree with is to defeat them at the ballot box. New Labour’s attempt to rebalance the system has led to popular frustration about the slow pace of change and a loss of confidence in our politics. Elective dictatorship is the worst form of government except all the others we have tried. It is time to go back to it.
No comments:
Post a Comment