Sunday, 22 November 2026

All Too Fit For Purpose

Alan Milburn proposes to strip doctors of their responsibility for signing people off, and he is encouraging the talk of nonexistent conditions such as “mild depression” and “mild anxiety”, so it is no wonder that Ruth Briel has just redeemed her shares in A.M. Strategy Limited and resigned from its Board. David Blunkett was sent out to defend the Milburn Review on Any Questions?, and PIP does not end at state pensionable age, so is he in receipt of it? And Caroline Wheeler and Vicky Spratt are only about a week behind this site:

Officials are drawing up plans to reform how universal credit works for people of all ages, potentially opening the door to new conditions for claimants, The i Paper understands. A “big reset” of Britain’s welfare system is expected amid growing concern about the rising number of people claiming health-related benefits without any requirement to engage with employment support [they did that until they either became too ill or were finally diagnosed as such, you clowns]. The UK’s main health-related benefits are the personal independence payment (PIP), the disability living allowance (DLA), employment and support allowance (ESA) and the health element of universal credit [an element that, unlike PIP, requires you to be found medically unfit for work, an extremely difficult thing to do: try it]. PIP helps cover the extra costs of a long-term health condition or disability and is not means-tested [nor has it anything to do with having, or not having a job, with many thousands of people able to work only because they received PIP], whereas universal credit is.

The plans could see new conditions placed on people claiming the health element of universal credit. Labour has introduced schemes to get people of all ages who are on health benefits into work, such as the “right to try”, which allows claimants to take a job without immediately losing welfare support, alongside an expansion of training, work experience and the offer of taxpayer-funded jobs. However, a source familiar with discussions at the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) said that these schemes are currently “voluntary” for universal credit claimants [if they have been driven damn near to death in the process of having been found medically unfit for work] and warned that this may change under Labour’s reforms. This could open the door to benefits sanctions for people who can work in some capacity [and therefore would not be on the health element of Universal Credit] but are not willing to engage with employment support.

Burnham faces challenge to reshape welfare system for all ages

It comes after The i Paper revealed that Blair-era former health minister Alan Milburn’s plan to overhaul benefits for young people could be used as a springboard to radically reshape the welfare system for millions over the age of 25. Milburn’s report proposed an “entirely new benefit system for young people”, with under-25s no longer able to claim the health element of universal credit, unless they have a severe disability or health condition which means they will likely never work.

Following the report’s publication, Prime Minister Andy Burnham suggested people with health conditions and disabilities will be supported into employment “right through the age range”. The source familiar with discussions at the DWP said: “There is serious concern about the rising number of people on health benefits with no requirement to engage with the DWP to support them back into work after they have been assessed as not fit for work.” [Take as long as you need.] They added: “Setting aside those people with disabilities or serious health conditions who are unable to work at all, there is much more that can be done to support people into work and extend conditionality for support.”

A major government review into the UK’s main disability benefit – PIP – is expected to this week conclude that the system is “not fit for purpose”. The disability minister Sir Stephen Timms is likely to recommend that PIP becomes more aligned with helping people participate in employment and society. He is also expected to call for reforms to Britain’s welfare system to better differentiate between the most severe health conditions and disabilities and milder or temporary conditions. While Milburn’s recommendations for young people have been broadly accepted by backbench Labour MPs, Burnham will need to convince former rebels to back any wider overhaul of the welfare system for over 25s. Sir Keir Starmer faced a damaging rebellion when he attempted to cut the benefits bill by £5bn, forcing him to make a major U-turn on restricting eligibility for PIP and the universal credit health top-up [no, there was no U-turn on that, which was cut by half for new claimants and frozen until 2030].

Shift away from automatically awarding benefits

The latest figures from the DWP show a record 6.7 million people of all ages claimed some combination of out-of-work benefits with no work requirement in March 2026. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden has already signalled a shift from supporting unemployment to focusing on what an individual can do, with greater emphasis on training, flexible jobs and extra conditions attached to receiving money from the state. Timms is expected to recommend that disability support should be aligned with this approach. The i Paper understands that any change will look at what a person is capable of doing (known as function) rather than automatically awarding benefits for certain conditions and cutting them for others. This is because some people have more than one condition. There is no plan for PIP to be means-tested [and if you believe that].

McFadden has said he wants a “big reset” of the welfare system as ministers examine how to help more disabled people and those with health conditions into work. He previously told The i Paper the UK’s system should do more to help people who can work with the right support, citing both financial and mental health benefits. McFadden has also previously criticised the universal credit system, saying there is a “design flaw” that makes it too easy for people to be “signed off and written off”, leaving them with no support or obligations. Currently, people undergo a work capability assessment to determine how a health condition or disability affects their ability to work. Those judged to have limited capability for work and work-related activity can be placed on a health-related benefit pathway without any requirement to look for a job [again, take as long as you need. But that is not PIP]. Meanwhile, people assessed as fit for work, or capable of preparing for work in the future, can face a cut to their benefits if they repeatedly refuse opportunities.

Moving forward, claimants who are able to work in some capacity [and who therefore would not be on the health element of Universal Credit] could be required to engage with employment support in order to receive benefits, with exceptions for those deemed unable to work under any circumstances. What is not yet clear is how a new disability support assessment would play out and how or when millions of people who currently claim benefits could be reassessed. Legislation is expected to reform Britain’s welfare system next year and more detailed proposals on what the changes will entail will come in early 2027. A Government spokesperson said the Milburn review and upcoming Timms Review “will help shape our next steps on welfare reform”. They added: “We are already overhauling Jobcentres to deliver more personalised work and skills advice for people of all ages, including through new digital tools; investing £2.5bn in our youth employment package and a record £3.5bn to help disabled people and those with long-term health conditions into work.”

Cannabis Use Unravelled His Mind

Emily Dugan writes:

Semi-naked, hissing and spitting at the hatch window to his cell, Alexander Lewis-Ranwell was in custody, having just attacked a pensioner with a 4ft logging saw. It was February 2019 and he had spent the day ranting about paedophiles, seeing animals and punching the glass. Officers in Barnstaple police station, north Devon, did not think it was safe to enter the cell. And yet Lewis-Ranwell, 27, walked free the following morning. Within six hours, in the grip of psychosis, he had bludgeoned three elderly men to death in their own homes.

Now, after combing through hours of police video, detention logs and witness testimony from an inquest and a trial, as well as speaking to the relatives of those killed, a joint investigation by The Sunday Times and BBC Radio 4’s File on 4 Investigates can expose the failings that allowed a seriously unwell man to roam the streets. It reveals how over a critical 48-hour period police officers failed to heed warnings from a national database and a mental health assessor, how they misunderstood the law, and that an unqualified medical professional was sent to examine Lewis-Ranwell and dismissed his unpredictable behaviour. Lewis-Ranwell’s mother begged for officers to keep him in custody, warning he was having a psychotic episode, but she was ignored too.

The errors made before the killing of Anthony Payne, Roger Carter and Dick Carter bear chilling similarities to those that would lead to Valdo Calocane killing three people in Nottingham four years later. The Nottingham attack might even have been prevented had the lessons from the Lewis-Ranwell case been learnt without delay. It was just after midnight when the police were called to the Castle Inn pub in Combe Martin. A man was behaving aggressively and propping up a cordless drill on the bar. Police arrived and escorted him out. The man told officers: “I feel like in the past [the barman] has done things to me when I was small. I don’t know why, it’s just a feeling that I’ve got.”

The man was Lewis-Ranwell, Albie to friends. The officers called in his details and discovered he had a recent history of mental health problems and criminal offences. Lewis-Ranwell grew up in Kent with his mother, Jill, an IT manager, and father, Barry, an insurance worker. They moved to Devon when he was 13, and his parents later separated. He got 11 GCSEs from the private West Buckland School near Exmoor, but during his A-levels he got bored and dropped out. He loved the outdoors and took on casual work, including as a horse trainer and fencing contractor, using the money to surf and snowboard around the world. But heavy cannabis use began to unravel his mind. In 2016 he threatened to kill his father and stepmother, stole his father’s car and was arrested after a police chase. He was sectioned and clinicians noted his delusions included believing he could talk to animals and that he was Jesus. He was diagnosed with drug-induced psychosis and, later, schizophrenia.

While in hospital he set fire to a bin in his wardrobe and took other patients hostage. It was reported to the police and he was transferred to a psychiatric crisis unit. When, after a month, no charges had been brought, his treating consultant psychiatrist warned in an email to Devon and Cornwall police that a criminal investigation should not be dropped “because he would learn that he could get away with such behaviour”. After seven months he received a caution but no charges. In 2017 his life stabilised briefly but then his cannabis use increased again. His mother tried to intervene: she wanted him to go to hospital. After he became “erratic, singing in mumbo-jumbo at the top of his voice”, she called the police, but they released him again. Three days later he was arrested in London for dangerous driving after a helicopter police chase up the M1. He was finally sectioned and taken to a psychiatric crisis ward in Somerset in August 2017. Within three months he was discharged.

Lewis-Ranwell was stable until the end of 2018, when he used cannabis and cocaine at a Christmas party and stopped taking his medication. The psychosis returned quickly. Outside the pub that February evening in 2019, and despite having checked his criminal record, police let him go, saying: “He isn’t causing any problems.” It was the first missed opportunity to stop him. Lewis-Ranwell refused a lift to the next town. As the officers drove off, one said: “He’s not right, is he?”

 ______________ 
08.00 
Lewis-Ranwell walked around the countryside in the dark and arrived at a farm near Ilfracombe. He let out a horse, and was found by its owner picking its hooves and refusing to leave. She called 999, telling officers that “he’s really scaring me”. When police arrived, Lewis-Ranwell said he had known the horse “from way back”, that he was under attack and that the horse was upset after having his testicles removed. Arresting officers can be heard saying: “He’s off his head.”

______________ 
09.50 
At Barnstaple police station, Lewis-Ranwell came across as calm and charming. He admitted to having been sectioned twice and that “they said it was psychosis”. But despite having an extensive entry on the police database, detaining officers did not enter any of these new details on to the detention log. A mental health worker based at the station noted Lewis-Ranwell had declined a mental health assessment and denied being a risk to himself or others.

____________ 
18.17 
Lewis-Ranwell spoke on the phone to his mother, who immediately recognised how unwell he was. She told the inquest the conversation was strange and that he became aggressive on the call, forcing officers to intervene and end it.

She called straight back to warn police that he was displaying signs of a psychotic episode. She told the inquest: “I thought they ought to know his type of behaviour, we’d seen it before. That he can get violent and aggressive, confrontational. I thought that was the right thing to do, to let them know.” No note was made on the detention log of her warnings about psychosis. Later that evening, his mother called again expressing “grave concerns should he be released”. She said: “I would have said that I was extremely concerned if he had been released, not just for the violence and the way he was, but also for his own safety.”

Nick Armstrong KC, who represented bereaved families at the inquest, said: “Not all mums are as effective and as energetic as Jill Lewis-Ranwell clearly was. Not only was she available, but she was actively on the phone telling the police: ‘This is what a psychotic descent looks like with my son. Here are the symptoms.’” An assessment by a mental health practitioner found “no immediate concerns” to prevent suitability for interview and that he was “able to fully engage and has good insight”, meaning an interview could go ahead. Police at the station put his behaviour down to him being difficult but were concerned enough for their own safety to question him through the hatch of his cell.

0:42
After being charged with burglary and criminal damage, he was bailed. Officers took him to a homeless centre in Barnstaple at 2.38am.

February 9
______________
06.00 
The homeless centre called the police to tell them Lewis-Ranwell had left. In the short time he was there, he threatened to kill a member of staff.

______________
08.45
John Ellis, then 82, looked out of the window of his bungalow at his smallholding in the countryside east of Barnstaple and saw his wife, Maureen, “gesticulating furiously”. A tall man was standing beside her with an enormous stick and a four-foot logging saw, trying to open the gate and let their alpacas out. When Mr Ellis rushed out, Lewis-Ranwell hit him with the stick and swung the saw at shoulder height, “aiming to decapitate me”. The saw cut the wrist Mr Ellis had put up in defence. Mrs Ellis raced back to the house and, on a terrified 999 call, screamed: “There’s a man attacking my husband with a saw!” She told the call handler: “Quick, please hurry up. He’s going to kill him.”

0:16
Lewis-Ranwell then brought the stick down on Mr Ellis’s head. The handle of the saw broke and Lewis-Ranwell ran off, losing his shoes in the mud, and sprinted in his socks through a field for a mile. When armed police arrived they wrestled him to the ground. He accused them of trying to rape him.

____________ 
10.21
After being arrested for grievous bodily harm, Lewis-Ranwell was booked into Barnstaple police station. There is nothing in the custody log to show officers recognised him as the man that left ten hours earlier. Because the officers who arrested him were armed, they were not allowed inside and did not convey to the custody desk what they had just seen. Nobody responsible for booking him in seemed aware of the severity of his psychosis. No mental health worker was based at the police station on weekends, so an out-of-hours service in Exeter was called. On a phone consultation, potential psychotic symptoms were noted.

The mental health professional concluded that he clearly required a Mental Health Act assessment. But it was nearly the end of her shift, so she could not see him in person. She called the emergency duty team for advice and was told there were four patients already needing to be seen and nobody was available. They also advised that a face-to-face consultation was required before a formal Mental Health Act assessment. This was wrong. A police doctor employed by the outsourcing firm G4S, Dr Mihail Pichiu, was called out to check on him. An officer told Pichiu that Lewis-Ranwell was saying he saw unicorns in the cell, smelling gas and “clearly needs an assessment”.

_____________ 
18.30 
Pichiu entered Lewis-Ranwell’s cell. Within 15 minutes he concluded that a Mental Health Act assessment was not necessary, noting: “He did not display any signs of delusions, psychosis or suicidal ideation.” Yet, a detention officer who accompanied Pichiu in the assessment told the inquest that Lewis-Ranwell made “absurd nonsensical replies”. These comments did not make it into the doctor’s notes. Lawyers for the family identified 17 mistakes made during the consultation. These included disregarding police observations of Lewis-Ranwell’s conduct, failing to record his odd behaviour in interview, ignoring the mental health practitioner’s phone assessment and falsely believing he could not access medical history without his consent.

At the inquest it transpired he was not qualified for the job, having worked predominantly on orthopaedic wards with almost no mental health experience. Pichiu appears to still practise medicine but his lawyer told the inquest he was referring himself to the General Medical Council. G4S no longer provides medical services to police forces but it is still commonplace for police doctors to be provided by an external agency.

In January this year, when the inquest was due to start, it emerged that CCTV from the cell that day had been lost. This delayed the inquest by another eight months, but the video was never recovered. However, an officer had reviewed the CCTV in summer 2019. Their notes of what it showed included a description of Lewis-Ranwell standing on a bench and pulling his shorts down to expose himself.

______________ 
22.46 
Pichiu’s decision that Lewis-Ranwell did not need a Mental Health Act assessment meant an interview with officers had to go ahead. In the police bodyworn footage of the short-lived interview, the extremity of Lewis-Ranwell’s psychosis is apparent. Police were shocked by the doctor’s decision. One would tell the inquest that Lewis-Ranwell was “one of the most mentally unwell individuals I can remember encountering in custody”. What officers did not realise was they had their own power under the Mental Health Act to detain him for public safety without a Mental Health Act assessment. Changes to the law in 2017 meant they could detain people suffering mental ill health for safety, even once inside a police station.

February 10 
_____________ 
09.38
Lewis-Ranwell had been in custody for almost 24 hours, so to keep him for a further 12 hours the Crown Prosecution Service wanted reassurance that an identity parade could take place within that time. This was impractical. Even though he had apparently confessed to the crime in the five-minute interview and left his shoes behind at the scene, the CPS believed there was not enough evidence to charge. Officers decided they had to let him go. Lewis-Ranwell left Barnstaple police station, climbed into a taxi to Exeter, offered a €100 note and asked where to buy cannabis. The taxi driver, Johnson Joseph, later said Lewis-Ranwell appeared to be on the brink of strangling him with the car’s rosary beads: “I just knew he was going to harm me … I felt very scared.” He let Lewis-Ranwell out at Copplestone near Crediton, where he got a rail replacement bus to Exeter St Davids railway station.

_____________ 
12.30 
After wandering down Bonhay Road, Lewis-Ranwell stopped at No 65. A note stuck to the door read: “Elderly man 80 years of age wants accommodation for himself and his pet cat.” Anthony Payne, 80, had just gone inside to feed his cats. Lewis-Ranwell went through the front door and left by the back eight minutes later. The next day Payne’s body was found by a friend. He had been bludgeoned to death in his bed with a hammer.

____________ 
15.15
Roger and Dick Carter, 84, were identical twins who had lived quietly at their Exeter home at 109 Cowick Lane for their entire lives. Their father had built the house and they shared the same bedroom from infancy, taking over the family mushroom-growing business. Their nephew, Jonathan Carter, recalled the twins as gentle men whose lives had been “totally intertwined”. He said: “They were unique in so far as they were very close. They shared a room a bit like Catholic brothers, I suppose. I don’t think one would have been able to live life as well as they did without the other.” Lewis-Ranwell tried to walk through their front gate but was ushered out by one of the brothers. He went to the back and climbed over a wall, grabbed a garden spade and used it to kill Dick in the kitchen. Roger died on the stairs having been hit on the head with the same spade. Immediately after the killings, Lewis-Ranwell walked up Cowick Hill and into a McColl’s to buy crisps and chocolate.

February 11
________________
05.18 
Lewis-Ranwell walked into the Rougemont hotel and demanded breakfast. He attacked the night porter with a glass bowl and chased him with a butcher’s knife, before chasing the chef and female night manager with a lamp stand, shouting: “I’m going to kill you. I’m going to kill the people in this hotel.” Police arrived and tasered him and he was finally sectioned. Later that day Payne’s body was found. 

Jonathan Carter, 60, was at work the next day when he got a call from a friend to say that his uncles’ home was surrounded by police cars and ambulances. The brewery where he worked in Exeter was a mile up the road and he drove straight over. Nobody told him what happened initially but when he saw his uncles’ dog Nero in the back of a police van, he feared the worst. “You could see in the face of that boxer dog it was traumatised. That’s when it really dawned on me.”

Lewis-Ranwell was arrested and charged with three murders. December 2019 After a two-week trial at Exeter crown court, a jury unanimously found Lewis-Ranwell not guilty by reason of insanity. Lewis-Ranwell was sent to Broadmoor, the secure psychiatric hospital in Berkshire, where he remains. Before delivering their verdict the jury passed a note to the judge raising concerns about the “state of psychiatric services in our county of Devon” and “failings in care”.

As the grieving families waited for answers, they were told an independent review of Lewis-Ranwell’s NHS care needed to be complete before the inquest could happen. Published in 2023, the review found “visible gaps” in services that “allowed him to be released when his mental state was relapsing”. When the inquest finally began this year, the Carter twins’ niece, Amanda Taylor, sat near Lewis-Ranwell’s mother and they supported each other through five weeks of painful evidence. Taylor said: “I couldn’t help feeling that Alex Lewis-Ranwell’s mother was going through a very similar and emotional experience at the inquest as I was. We had both lost people we loved due to errors made by the system.

“Repeatedly at the inquest we were dumbfounded by just how much the police appeared to have conveniently forgotten. The disappearance of the CCTV footage, which could have shown just how unwell her son was, had been the final straw in what was already a devastating catalogue of failures. If just one of those failures had not occurred, our dear uncles might still be here, and Jill Lewis-Ranwell would still have her son in her life. That is an incredibly painful thing to live with for us both.”

After the initial raw emotion of her uncles’ deaths, Taylor has come to feel empathy for the man who killed them, saying: “He was as much a victim of those failures as our family was.” Julian Hendy, who established the charity Hundred Families after his father was fatally stabbed by a man with a long history of mental health problems, is infuriated by the delays. He said: “It seems to me that had the inquest in this case been held sooner, lessons might well have been learnt that would have prevented killings in other similar cases since.”

The most striking of these is the killings by Calocane in Nottingham in 2023. “The inquiry into the Nottingham killings heard evidence on many similar themes — particularly the failure to assess and manage the risk and for police and mental health services to share critical information and work effectively together. In my view had the lessons in the Lewis-Ranwell case been learnt earlier, and effective action taken, there is a real chance that the Nottingham attacks could well have been prevented.”

In the case of Calocane, investigators found that his risk was not fully understood, managed, documented or communicated, that there were missed opportunities to detain him under the Mental Health Act, and that the concerns of his family were also not properly considered. Hendy wants urgent reform to prevent more deaths. “There are around 100 to 120 mental health related killings in the UK each and every year. It’s like a Hillsborough every year and it doesn’t get the attention that it merits,” he said.

Six years, no apology

Shortly after his trial, Lewis-Ranwell pursued a civil claim against the police, G4S and mental health services, for failing to keep him in custody or treat his psychosis. The Supreme Court blocked his claim. The families have never had an apology, having complained to police in 2020. Devon and Cornwall Police referred itself to the Independent Office for Police Conduct, which said the force could investigate itself. The families were contacted by an investigating officer more than two years ago but have heard nothing since.

Last week the health service and police said they had made changes to ensure that workers understood how to detain someone under the Mental Health Act, and to ensure that medical information is shared. Both said they would reflect on the recommendations of the inquest jury. Police said they were waiting to see whether a formal prevention of future death notice was issued by the coroner and would consider any recommendations. Custody sergeants and detention officers are receiving training to accurately record risks and observations about detainees.

A police spokesman said: “Our thoughts, as always, remain with the loved ones of Anthony Payne and Dick and Roger Carter. The inquest heard evidence from a number of police witnesses. Areas of learning and change identified during the inquest and prior reviews are being, and have been, addressed. We continue to make every possible effort to ensure the security and safety of any member of the public admitted into police custody, including during their detention and release.”

Devon Partnership NHS Trust said: “We would like to extend our sympathies to the families of Richard and Roger Carter and Anthony Payne. Our organisation will reflect on the jury's conclusions and we remain committed to continuous learning and ensuring that improvements are embedded in our systems and practice.” Dr Pichiu declined to comment. G4S said: “We offer our condolences to the families affected by these tragic events.”

The fight for an apology continues. Taylor said: “All I want is for just one of the agencies involved to stand up and say, ‘We are so sorry. Serious mistakes were made. We recognise the devastating consequences of those failures, and we will do everything in our power to make sure this never happens again.’ But we haven’t even had that. Not one of them has had the courage or the compassion to say it. It makes me incredibly angry. These are the very systems that are supposed to act as a safety net, to protect people when they are at their most vulnerable. Yet when those systems fail so catastrophically, where is the accountability?”

Why Was He Released? was made by 2 Degrees West. It will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4 at 8pm on Tuesday November 24 and available on BBC Sounds.

Milestones On Our Route To Barbarity


Europe is now firmly on the road back to the Stone Age. This was the week of the broken bridges. Ukraine, or rather the western powers acting in its name, wrecked the great Kerch bridge linking Crimea to Russia. Russia took revenge by smashing bridges over the River Dnieper in Kiev. Is there any greater symbol of progress and order than a bridge? Think of the majestic Forth railway bridge, or the lovely stone bridge between Cornwall and England near Gunnislake. Rudyard Kipling, in his thrilling Song Of The English, summed up the tasks of civilisation: ‘Keep ye the Law – be swift in all obedience. Clear the land of evil, drive the road and bridge the ford.’ When men so completely lose control of themselves that they start deliberately wrecking such things, where will they stop? Yet we pour more and more fuel on to this stinking fire. British politicians who ten years ago could not have spelt ‘Ukraine’ are now determined to destroy it in order to save it. God protect us from such saviours.

And:

The side effects are often the key thing about any drug. Many of us recall Thalidomide for that reason. It fought off morning sickness during pregnancy and so seemed to be a blessing. It was advertised as ‘astonishingly safe’ and ‘non-toxic’. Alas, it also led to terrible birth defects. About 10,000 children in 46 countries were affected. It was one of the great medical tragedies of its age. Many who lived through that time still shudder at the mention of the word. Its dangers had not been fully discovered when it went on sale.

Yet now, the trusted and familiar company, Boots, is launching a new supposed miracle drug on British high streets. A smiley website proclaims: ‘We provide pharmaceutical-grade medical cannabis to help manage chronic symptoms, with every treatment plan guided by our specialist clinicians to ensure safe, personally tailored care.’ And in this case the drug is being launched on the market when at least one of its dangers is famous. It can make you mentally ill. What pain is worth that risk?

We know this thanks to the European EU-GEI study, published in 2019. Daily users of cannabis are more than three times as likely to develop psychosis as those who never use it. Daily use of high-potency (‘skunk’) cannabis raises the risk to nearly five times. My own view is that we are only beginning to grasp the grave risks of this drug.

Last week Xander Robinson wrote in The Times: ‘My brother Oliver died on November 24, 2023, aged 34. In 2022, after a single video consultation, a private clinic [not Boots, obviously, who were not in the business at the time] prescribed him high-strength cannabis.He had recurrent depression, had been admitted to psychiatric hospital twice and had been diagnosed with cannabis dependency. His psychiatrists considered cannabis an obstacle to his recovery. The clinic prescribed it anyway. In January a coroner ruled that the prescription had contributed to him taking his own life.’

You might like to know that sad story, if you are considering using Boots, or anyone else, in pursuit of ‘medical marijuana’. Boots offers it for lower back pain, arthritis, insomnia and ‘general anxiety disorder’ among several other conditions. They say ‘UK specialists can usually only consider cannabis-based medicine once at least two other licensed treatments haven’t worked well enough for you.’ But how on earth can the effectiveness of any drug against such things be objectively measured? I accept that cannabis may have medical properties, though I think the evidence so far is scanty and obscure. But I think the main effect of this move by Boots will be to provide respectability for a drug that is anything but respectable.

Campaigners for legal dope boasted nearly 50 years ago that they would use medical marijuana to get pot a good name. They will be delighted. So will the Billionaire Big Dope lobby, which longs to see cannabis shops on every high street, plus unregulated sales through the internet. I am astounded at how little criticism there has been. It is as if one of our big department store chains announced plans to operate brothels (nice clean ones, obviously) in their shops, and nobody cared. We have about three minutes to wake up to the scale of this danger before the battle is irreversibly lost.

“Medical marijuana” does not exist. When we need aspirin, we do not eat bark. But there cannot be a “free” market in general, yet not in drugs, or prostitution, or pornography, or unrestricted alcohol, or unrestricted gambling. That is an important part of why there must not be a “free” market in general, which is a political choice, not a law of nature. Enacting and enforcing laws against drugs, prostitution and pornography, and regulating alcohol, tobacco and gambling, are clear examples of State intervention in, and regulation of, the economy. Radical change would be impossible if the workers, the youth and the poor were in a state of stupefaction, and that baleful situation, which has been contrived in the past, is being contrived again today. Volodymyr Zelensky has a cocaine habit, Ukraine is globally important both to heroin-trafficking and to people-trafficking, and it is legalising pornography to pay for the war.

We need a single category of illegal drug, including cannabis, with a crackdown on possession, including a mandatory sentence of two years for a first offence, three years for a second offence, four years for a third offence, and so on. I no longer believe in prison sentences that included the possibility of release in less than 12 months; in that case, then your crime was not bad enough to warrant imprisonment, which the possession of drugs is. We need to restore the specific criminal offence of allowing one’s premises to be used for illegal drug purposes. We need Hitchens’s The War We Never Fought to be taught in schools. And we need to start fighting that war, not this one.

The Principle Remains Simple

Paul Knaggs writes:

On Friday in Brussels, a string quintet played the anthems of both sides as Andy Burnham shook hands with Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa. The Prime Minister told the room “This is a good day for Britain.” Von der Leyen called it a “turning point” in relations. Three agreements were sealed. There is a food and farming deal, a link between the two carbon trading schemes, and a youth mobility scheme that would let 100,000 young Europeans live and work in Britain for up to three years, with the same right for young Britons in the EU. The headline figure is a gift to any press office. The government estimates the package will add 0.5% to GDP, about £17 billion, by 2040. That date is fourteen years away. In the last six years, the world has given us a pandemic, a land war in Europe and an energy shock. Every one of those billions rests on a model, and every model rests on a stack of ifs. None of it arrives soon either. The food deal is not due until March 2028, and the youth scheme promises first travel no later than January 2030.

Within hours, the familiar chorus in London was urging the government to keep going until Britain is back inside the bloc. Burnham has given them reason to hope. He has said he would like Britain to rejoin the EU within his lifetime. His Energy Secretary, Ed Miliband, said that “of course all the options will be on the table.” Before the British working class is marched back towards Brussels under the banner of economic common sense, it is worth looking closely at the machine. The EU is not just a trading club that sometimes overreaches. Its law-making system is built to keep the people it governs at arm’s length. Decisive power sits with an unelected executive that drafts the rules, and the final deals are struck behind closed doors. Concentrated capital is far better placed than the ordinary citizen to shape them.

Dynamic Alignment: The Price Not on the Poster 

The food deal is not simply a bonfire of paperwork. In March, Maroš Šefčovič, the Commission’s chief negotiator with Britain, set out the aim plainly. He wanted a common food-standards area, achieved “through the UK’s dynamic alignment with EU SPS rules.” Dynamic alignment means that when Brussels changes its food, plant and animal-health rules, Britain changes with it. As the House of Lords Library puts it, the UK would be required to follow future changes in EU law. Jill Rutter of the Institute for Government summed it up in one word: Britain becomes a rule-taker for food and farming.

The government’s factsheet, published three days before the summit, says nothing about dynamic alignment, parliamentary scrutiny of new EU rules or the role of the European Court of Justice. The Business Secretary went further on the radio. Jonathan Reynolds claimed on LBC that EU dynamic alignment rules would not apply to Britain under the deal. Either the Commission’s negotiator has misunderstood his own deal, or the public is being told a comfortable story. This is the point where the old complaint about the EU’s democratic deficit stops being academic. As a member, Britain had a commissioner, MEPs and a vote in the Council, however often it lost. Under dynamic alignment it has none of these. It simply receives law written in rooms it cannot enter. If the EU was undemocratic for its members, it is doubly so for a country that agrees to follow it from outside.

Outsourcing the Hard Part: Why Alignment By Stealth 

There is an older story underneath Friday’s handshakes. Since 2016, much of Britain’s political class has never really wanted to leave, and has shown even less appetite for the hard work of deciding what an independent country should do with its freedom. The tools were there: control over state aid, public procurement, trade and industrial strategy. Very little was built with them. Successive governments treated Brexit as damage to be limited, not a power to be used.

Yet those same politicians know it is dangerous to defy a democratic decision openly. In 2019 the escape hatch was a second referendum. Today the route is quieter. Burnham keeps his red lines for this Parliament while saying a deeper reset will wait for the next. Over the coming year, London and Brussels will hold what he calls an “informal brainstorming process” on the future relationship, and the options are to be put to the public eventually. In the meantime, every alignment clause moves the starting line a little closer to Brussels. By the time anyone is asked, half the answer will already have been written.

Bertolt Brecht once mocked a government so disappointed in its citizens that it might find it simpler to dissolve the people and elect another. In European politics that joke has hardened into a habit. Denmark voted against the Maastricht Treaty in 1992 and was asked again. Ireland rejected the Nice Treaty in 2001 and the Lisbon Treaty in 2008, and on both occasions was sent back to the polls until it gave the right answer. Public opinion in Britain has moved, and polling now suggests that most people think leaving was a mistake. If the country wants to rejoin, it has every right to say so. The objection here is not to asking the question. It is to the method: hollowing out a decision by stealth, then presenting the public with a done deal dressed up as a choice.

That method announces contempt for democratic majorities, and it raises a harder question for our institutions. If parties, elections and parliaments exist not to let the people create and control governments, but to manage them, why should anyone take part? Britain voted to leave in 2016, on a turnout higher than at any general election since 1992. Both main parties stood in 2017 promising to honour the result, and in 2019 the country gave a large majority to the party that promised to get it done. If decisions made again and again can be quietly unpicked whenever representatives find them inconvenient, what are those institutions for? The working class voters who turned out in 2016 will draw their own conclusions, and no one in Westminster should be surprised by them. To see why the method matters, look at the machine Britain is being steered back towards.

How the EU Machine Works: Commission and Parliament 

Start with the European Commission. It has 27 commissioners, one from each member state, every one of them appointed by national governments and not one of them elected. Yet this body holds the sole right to propose almost all EU law. Every directive that ever reshaped a British industry began as a Commission draft, written by people no voter could remove. At the top sits a president who has never faced the voters. In 2019 Ursula von der Leyen did not stand in the European elections. She was not even a party’s lead candidate. Her own centre-right group had campaigned behind Manfred Weber. After days of haggling behind closed doors, EU leaders threw him aside and produced Germany’s defence minister, a politician who had neither campaigned nor publicly expressed interest in the job. 

MEPs were furious. The Greens’ leader, Ska Keller, called it a “backroom stitch-up” and “grotesque”, a deal that satisfied nothing but party power games. The Dutch Green MEP Bas Eickhout accused the Council of slaughtering the rule of law to hand out jobs for Merkel, Macron and Sánchez. Then the Parliament was handed a ballot with one name on it. Von der Leyen scraped through by nine votes above the minimum. In 2024 the show was given better costumes. Von der Leyen was named her party’s lead candidate and toured Europe with branded mugs and hoodies, yet once again she refused to stand for Parliament. Almost nobody she met on the campaign trail could vote for her. The German Green MEP Daniel Freund pointed out that she was seeking the most powerful office in the EU “without even appearing on a single ballot paper.” When the votes were counted, EU leaders proposed one candidate: her. MEPs were again offered a yes or a no, and she obtained 401 votes. A choice of one is not an election. It is a coronation with a show of hands.

The European Parliament is the institution the EU’s defenders reach for whenever the word democracy comes up. Its 720 MEPs are elected, and since the Lisbon Treaty they share the passing of most laws with national ministers. But they cannot start a single one. They can ask the Commission to propose a law, and the Commission can refuse, provided it explains itself. In 2019 MEPs had the chance to defend the lead-candidate system, the one democratic innovation they had fought for. They protested loudly about the stitch-up and then voted the winner in anyway. A parliament that cannot bring a bill, and that rubber-stamps an executive chosen by heads of government, is not a parliament as Britain understands the word.

In theory, the Parliament can sack the Commission. In practice the bar is a two-thirds majority, and no censure motion has ever passed. The one time the threat bit was in 1999. The Santer Commission resigned after an independent report on fraud and mismanagement, before MEPs could throw it out. The von der Leyen Commission has faced a string of censure motions since. In July 2025 MEPs rejected one by 360 votes to 175. In October 2025 it saw off two more, one of them tabled by the Left group. In January 2026 another fell by 390 votes to 165. The censure motions were not about nothing. In May 2025 the EU’s own General Court annulled the Commission’s refusal to give a New York Times journalist access to text messages between von der Leyen and Albert Bourla, the chief executive of Pfizer. Those messages were exchanged while the bloc was buying billions of vaccine doses. The Commission’s defence was that it could not find them.

Where EU Law Is Really Made: The Trilogues 

The formal procedure is not where most EU laws are settled. The real bargaining happens in “trilogues”, closed meetings of small negotiating teams from the Parliament, the Council and the Commission. When the EU Ombudsman, Emily O’Reilly, investigated in 2016, she found that around 85% of EU laws were being agreed at first reading thanks to these talks, up from 29% two terms earlier. She warned that deal-making behind closed doors risked “the creation of public suspicion and uncertainty”. Secrecy does not keep everyone out. The environmental lawyers ClientEarth note that information about these negotiations still reaches the lobby groups with the most money and the best connections. The public waits outside while the best-funded interests pick up what is going on inside.

Those interests are well funded indeed. A study by Corporate Europe Observatory and LobbyControl found that digital industry lobby spending in Brussels reached €151 million a year, up from €113 million in 2023. In the first half of 2025, Big Tech met senior Commission staff 146 times, more than once every working day. A corner shop, a family haulier or a small food processor has no lobbyist in Brussels. Each of them has to comply with whatever comes out of those rooms. Compliance costs land hardest on firms without legal departments, and that steadily tilts the market towards the giants. The Council of the EU is where national ministers vote. Most decisions go through qualified majority voting, which needs 55 per cent of member states representing 65 per cent of the EU’s population. As a member, Britain could be outvoted and still bound. Under alignment, it is not even in the room to be outvoted.

A Court That Writes The Market Into Stone 

Then there is the Court of Justice. Its rulings carry real weight for the working class, and the labour movement should not forget them. In the Viking and Laval cases of 2007, the Court held that strike action could be an unlawful restriction on a company’s freedom to set up business or provide services across borders. In Laval, the target of the action was a Latvian contractor undercutting wages on a Swedish building site. A court in Luxembourg weighed a trade union’s most basic weapon against a business’s market freedoms and came down on the side of the business.

During the euro crisis, the treaties appeared to rule out bailing out member states. In the Pringle case of 2012, the Court read that no-bailout clause narrowly enough to let the eurozone’s permanent rescue fund go ahead. Supporters call that pragmatism. Critics see a court that bends the treaties when the single currency is at stake, and they have a point. The price of those rescues fell on the Greek working class. In July 2015 Greeks voted decisively in a referendum to reject the bailout terms. Within days their government signed up to harsher ones, after the European Central Bank had squeezed the banks shut.

Read The Small Print 

The great EU reset is being sold to the British public as an economic triumph. Ministers boast that £6.5 billion of British exports, including steel and aluminium, will escape the EU’s carbon border tax, while farmers will finally be freed from costly checks at the border. Strip away the publicity and the picture looks rather different. That £6.5 billion is the value of exports potentially covered by an exemption, not £6.5 billion in savings. The government’s own explainer describes the deal as “creating the conditions for an exemption”. The carbon trading link is not expected to operate until January 2028, and the EU’s side of the exemption is still subject to EU legislative procedures. The agricultural agreement is scheduled for March 2028. The government is celebrating benefits that have yet to arrive while presenting projected economic gains as though they were money already in the pockets of British families. Ministers boast of a £17 billion boost by 2040 from Andy Burnham’s Brussels reset. The small print reveals delayed 2028 start dates and binding EU rules Westminster cannot vote on.

And what is Britain giving up in exchange? The government’s own documents provide the answer: dynamic alignment. The food agreement will, in Whitehall’s words, “function on the basis of” the UK and EU applying the same rules, at the same time, on an ongoing basis. England’s own rules on gene-edited crops survive only until July 2028, after which the EU’s framework takes over. Under the emissions trading agreement, Britain will follow the EU rules listed in the treaty as they change. Even proposals to extend Britain’s own carbon scheme to new activities or gases must be submitted to the European Commission for approval. If Brussels widens its scheme and Britain declines to follow, the EU may take temporary measures against it. The UK will have a seat on joint committees, which decide by mutual consent, so in principle Britain can say no. In practice, saying no puts the benefits of the deal at risk. The government calls what Britain gets in return “an early decision-shaping role” on EU rules in development. Shaping is not deciding. A voice is no substitute for a vote when somebody else writes the legislation. 

We are told that the European Union is democratic because its Parliament is elected and national governments sit on its Council. That is true, but it rather misses the point. Britain is no longer represented in either institution. Yet Westminster is being asked to accept continuing regulatory obligations arising from decisions taken by those institutions. And even when Britain was a member, national elections could not simply overturn treaty obligations. Competition law, state-aid controls and the free movement of capital were embedded in a legal framework beyond the authority of any single elected government.

Why It Will Never Change 

“There will be no compromise on the single market. Never, never, never.” – Michel Barnier (2020) 

The treaties permit public ownership, but that freedom comes with conditions. A government may nationalise a railway, water company or steelworks, yet the financing and operation of public enterprises remain subject to EU competition and state-aid rules. Where public investment counts as aid that must be notified, it cannot proceed until the Commission has approved it. For a socialist government seeking to rebuild industry, those are real constraints on democratic economic policy. Nor can those foundations easily be rewritten. Fundamental treaty change normally requires unanimity among member governments followed by ratification in every member state. France and the Netherlands rejected the proposed European Constitution in 2005, only for much of its institutional substance to return through the Lisbon Treaty. The lesson was uncomfortable: European integration could continue even after electorates had rejected the constitutional project presented to them.

The Tribune campaigned to leave precisely because of these questions of democratic accountability and economic sovereignty. We wanted the freedom to rebuild British industry, restore public ownership and put the interests of the working class before the demands of an economic system built around competition and the free movement of capital. Nobody disputes the importance of trading with our European neighbours. Removing unnecessary barriers is welcome where it genuinely helps British producers. But every agreement must be judged against the obligations it creates, the powers it restricts and the benefits it actually delivers. An agreement that makes trade easier in return for accepting future rules we cannot vote on carries a democratic cost, however attractive the government’s economic forecasts might appear. 

The British people voted to leave the European Union. They did not vote to replace membership with a succession of agreements that gradually return its authority over British law without restoring Britain’s representation. The principle remains simple: those who make the laws governing our country must ultimately be accountable to the people who live under them.

A Commons Vote On Every EU Rule Britain Adopts

“The conception of the Common Market is the result of a political malaise following the failure of Socialists to use the sovereign power of their parliaments to plan their economic life.” – Nye Bevan 

The legislation to put Friday’s deals into effect enters Parliament next week. MPs should treat it as the most important constitutional question of this Parliament, not a technical trade bill. At a minimum, every new EU rule Britain is expected to adopt should come before the Commons with a vote. The full legal texts should be published before MPs are asked to approve anything. There should be a clear exit route if Brussels changes the rules in ways no British voter would accept. Any step beyond the government’s red lines should be decided openly by the public, not reached by quiet drift. For forty years we were told Britain needed a seat at the table. Dynamic alignment is the first deal that asks us to eat whatever is served without even offering us a chair.

Saturday, 21 November 2026

Restore Balance

Rishi Sunak was never the worst, and a bit more on parliamentary oversight could almost make him Tony Benn here:

One thing that Andy Burnham should do in his ten-year plan is give himself more power. He should concentrate on speeding up our sclerotic system of government, removing the obstacles to action. This is where he should be radical and prepared to break with New Labour shibboleths. It isn’t healthy for democracy when governments of all stripes find it so hard to deliver what they have promised; it makes voters cynical and dissatisfied.

Britain used to be criticised for being an elective dictatorship. Yet when you are prime minister, you don’t feel like much of a dictator. You are constantly told of the need to consult on this and the risk of judicial review on that, or that the decision actually rests with some quango. Even Sir Keir Starmer, a human rights lawyer, complained that “every time I go to pull a lever there are a whole bunch of regulations, consultations, arm’s-length bodies” in the way.

This is a rare moment when nearly all parties can see that our system of government needs fixing. Prime ministers having more power isn’t anti-democratic. Indeed, the biggest threat to our democracy is that voters keep voting for change and nothing happens. We have come to fetishise process at the expense of outcomes.

We won’t restore balance until we scrap many of the checks and balances that have accumulated over the past 30 years. Labour ministers, having been out of power for so long, have been surprised by their experience in government. They’ve asked my opinion on procedural changes that, if they had come from me or any other Tory prime minister, they would have denounced as the end of civilisation. Kemi Badenoch, to her credit, has been making the case for change since she first ran to be Tory leader in 2022.

Burnham has made some encouraging noises about taking on the “unaccountable state”. His aim should be a radical transfer of power from unelected and unaccountable bodies to elected and accountable ministers. There are now more than 300 arm’s-length public bodies. Yes, there are some things we don’t want politicians in charge of — such as the Electoral Commission and the Office for National Statistics — but too often quangos remove much-needed democratic accountability. Natural England was able, without explicit parliamentary consent, to issue planning advice which held back the construction of 100,000 homes. When we attempted to overturn it, the House of Lords stopped us. It was an unholy alliance of the unaccountable and the unelected.

The joke that the British government has the engine of a lawnmower and the brakes of a Rolls-Royce has become painfully close to the truth. Too often, rather than making a decision and getting on with it, ministers go out to consultation: about 500 times a year. The government is trying to tackle this, but it needs to go further and faster, removing statutory duties to consult, requirements to conduct impact assessments and the like. This may sound cavalier, but it is for parliament to scrutinise and for elections to act as our error-correction mechanism.

Consultations are often just vehicles for special pleading — more than 70 per cent of the responses to Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms came from visa-holders, not British citizens — and create all sorts of legal traps. One consultation on welfare reform was struck down by the courts, which decided, among other things, that we had not been clear about our motivation. It is madness to have judges trying to open windows into ministers’ souls to work out what they were really thinking.

The bar for a judicial review used to be high. You had to argue that a decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have taken it. But the Human Rights Act changed our legal culture. It introduced a new test of proportionality for anything that touched a convention right. That is far more subjective. The government can lose if it could have used a less intrusive measure to achieve the same result or if the judge simply believes it has not balanced competing interests properly. This approach has now seeped into our common law, leading to a more litigious culture and courts ruling on trade-offs that should be a matter for parliament.

Perhaps the biggest problem, though, with this lower bar for judicial review is the chilling effect it has. The old reasonableness test was so straightforward you didn’t need to be a lawyer to understand it; ministers could act with confidence. But the new grounds are far less clear. I lost count of the number of times I was told, “You can’t do that — you’ll be JR-ed.” Often, if you pushed back, you would find there was a legal way through. Sometimes it just required a different lawyer. But there simply wasn’t time to do that in every case. My other worry: if I was being told this in meetings as prime minister, how many ideas never made it up to my desk because of the perceived risk?

Parliament should legislate to return to the old, higher bar for judicial review. It will require several changes, including scrapping the Human Rights Act — which is why Labour will balk at it. But if we persist with the present system, prime ministers will continue to have to govern with the handbrake on. Legislation created the problem, and legislation can fix it.

The vogue for writing duties and targets into law is a classic illustration of the problem. Things such as the public sector equality duty and wide-ranging employment laws are an invitation to judicial overreach. Legislating for net zero by 2050, rather than simply making a commitment, invites legal challenges to a whole slew of policy-making and requires judges to rule on inherently political choices that should be made by MPs. In 2024 Friends of the Earth won its second case in two years over our climate action plans, and the courts ordered us to rewrite them. Labour will run into the same problem if it tries to change the zero-emissions vehicle mandate. The Climate Change Committee, another quango, is already warning that doing so would put legally binding targets at risk.

The criticism of Britain as an elective dictatorship came from the Conservative politician Lord Hailsham, who was angry that even slim governing majorities gave Labour the authority to make huge changes. But the right response to policies you disagree with is to defeat them at the ballot box. New Labour’s attempt to rebalance the system has led to popular frustration about the slow pace of change and a loss of confidence in our politics. Elective dictatorship is the worst form of government except all the others we have tried. It is time to go back to it.

Rock, Star

My only opinion on Grand Theft Auto VI is that a primary and secondary school classmate of mine won a BAFTA for his work on Grand Theft Auto V. And last year, a gamer was raised to the altars. You can keep your console and still find consolation. 

There is hope, then, for a man who, when Donald Trump was last President, was an ICT teacher at a North London comp, with a sideline in video games. Having expressed his opposition to immigration by moving to another country, his monarchism by moving from a monarchy to a republic, and his integralism-without-the-Pope by moving to the land of Article VI Clause 3 and of the First Amendment, Calvin Robinson is clearly a tortured soul.

Since the Church of England refused to ordain him, he has joined a different denomination every year until so far in 2026, lasting only nine days in last year's, and with the fifth and latest being the English Catholic Church in North America, Sarumites in fiddleback chasubles, whose own claimed membership is 315 souls, albeit "in 35 countries". Which 35 countries, exactly? It has one fifth that many congregations.

Still, what must be Robinson's impending deportation from the United States from which he had expressed the desire to "drive out the Jews" will add England as the thirty-sixth until such time as he finally constituted a denomination in his own person. Between that and the mutual excommunications among rival Orthodox bodies in Ukraine, Follow Peter. If everyone, including those aboard his Barque, had done that, then Muslims would not be on course to outnumber Christians by 2035, which is almost exclusively because of their higher birth rate.

As we rebuild our civilisation from scratch after what has been confirmed in the Epstein Files, we need to re-learn structured daily prayer, setting aside one day in seven, fasting, almsgiving, pilgrimage, the global community of faith as the primary focus of personal allegiance and locus of personal identity, the lesser outward and greater inward struggle, the need for a comprehensive and coherent critique both of capitalism and of Marxism, the coherence between faith and reason, and a consequent integrated view of art and science. The answer to the challenge of the Sunna is Sacred Tradition. The answer to the challenge of Sufism is our own tradition of mysticism and monasticism. And the answer to the challenge of the Imamate is the Petrine Office. Liberal Catholics will be the last to see the point. Although, like everyone else, they may buy the book here.

From Spare To Reserve?

General Sir Rob Magowan has told Sky News that Britain was conducting offensive cyber operations against Russia, China, Iran and North Korea. He would never have said that if it had been true, but only if he had wanted people to think that it was.

And North Korea is supposed to be an unelectrified joke, so how could it have a nuclear weapons programme, why should we be frightened of a few thousand of its troops in Kursk, and how could it be launching cyberattacks? But have no fear, Prince Harry is standing by.