Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Still Hazy After All These Years

Alan Milburn was no NEET. From 1975 to 1986, between the ages of 17 and 28, he ran a Newcastle Trotskyist bookshop called Days of Hope, known as “Haze of Dope”. It obviously cost far more than it could possibly have been making, but it clearly suited someone’s purposes to have a distraction from the Communist Party bookshop down the road.

On 15th January 2005, Tony Benn wrote in his diary that, “Alan Milburn was at the Fabian Society Conference. I find the man absolutely impossible to watch. He’d be a wonderful Conservative leader for them, and this idea that New Labour has got anything whatsoever to do with the Labour Party or the trade union movement or the working class movement, is a complete illusion, and it would be better if he was the leader of the Tory Party.”

And on 10 December 2009, a Guardian roundup of what was then very much the ongoing MPs’ expenses scandal, included the following:

Alan Milburn, the former health secretary, claimed £6.75 for John Lewis hand wash. "Soap" was written on his expense claim form in January 2009. He claimed £74.50 for kitchenware and glasses from David Mellor in Sloane Square, £87.50 for ground rent and £96 for cleaning. In February this year he claimed £151.55 for a floor lamp and ceiling light from John Lewis and bulbs. A further £19.50 was claimed for a sheet set from M&S.

A month later, in March, he submitted a £760.85 claim for household items, from John Lewis. The items included a Pure Siesta DAB digital clock (£58.60), lacquered silver place mats (£48), lacquered silver coaster sets (£19.50), a king-size duck down duvet (£107) and six pillow protectors (£58.50).

The household items also included a baking sheet, roasting dish, and four mini-quiche dishes without prices displayed and a saute pan and chopping boards.

In July 2008, he received a letter demanding an "overdue" £133.34 for the upkeep of his London flat. It said: "Should payment not be received within 14 days of the date of this letter, an administration charge of £50 plus VAT and interest on the arrears will be calculated at 4% above the base rate."

Between June and July 2008 he claimed for a £19.99 Argos iron and a £14.95 Tesco vacuum cleaner. In April 2009, Milburn claimed £55 for towels "for London flat". The towels were from John Lewis.

Do you recall voting for Milburn to run the country? He has not contested an election of any kind in 21 years. Shoulders have been shrugged at The Guardian’s disclosure that his real plan was to take away sickness and disability benefits from everyone. Tell us something we didn’t know. What next? Jeffrey Epstein was murdered? So much for the Timms Review, when it was always going to be straightforward abolition. With a Commons majority of the present size, whatever the Government does is what it wants to do, and this is that. At the same time, Milburn was given this report to write to order by Keir Starmer, making it an expression of the demob happiness of a Government and a party that assumed that Nigel Farage would be Prime Minister soon enough, much as during the 1997 General Election campaign, the Conservatives amused themselves by hinting at the withdrawal of the state retirement pension from people who were already claiming it.

It is these measures that have never worked. The ones under the Conservatives increased the disability employment gap. There were no employment gains from the cuts to Employment Support Allowance. The health element of Universal Credit has been halved for new claimants, and frozen until 2030, yet the number of new claims has stayed the same. But like the last round, this round is to see off Reform UK, which is collapsing on its own, and to beg for the affection, which will never be forthcoming, of the right-wing papers whose circulation was already in freefall even before considering that its readers would gnaw off their own arms before they voted Labour. In any case, cuts to disability benefits are supported by only five per cent of Labour voters, seven per cent of Conservative voters, and 11 per cent of Reform voters.

When James Purnell resigned from Gordon Brown’s Cabinet as part of an attempt to replace Brown with David Miliband, then it was because Purnell had failed to persuade Brown to let him charge 26.8 per cent interest on crisis loans. Only in Britain is there this sheer venom and bile towards the disabled, for whom no politician or journalist ever speaks. Milburn is only the latest in a long line to be fawned over as he bragged about his toughness in kicking paraplegics out of their wheelchairs. Key players in the last stage rebellion are now in government or realistically hope to be so. More Labour MPs will vote against Rosebank than will vote against this.

Far from ballooning, the percentage of GDP spent on benefits is much as it has always been, and lower than it was under David Cameron. Andy Burnham says that he wants to end homelessness, yet who would make the disabled live on £78 per week, a great deal less than in any other Western country. There is much talk of Denmark, but the weekly figure there is £580. As recently as March, Burnham claimed to have opposed such cuts, but he remained and remains listed as a Commissioner of Iain Duncan Smith’s Centre for Social Justice, so the signs were always there. The Government itself says that only two per cent of those disabled people whom these cuts affected would be put on programmes to “support” them into work. The other 98 per cent would be abandoned to starve, freeze, kill themselves, or whatever.

And what of that “support”? A young person who has graduated both from Oxford and from Cambridge cannot find work, so what hope those in their sixties who had been signed off for years? If your GP is not going to responsible for signing you off or not, then who is? Palantir? BlackRock? The Tony Blair Institute? In any event, it would be someone who was paid by the number of claims rejected, in accordance with custom and practice. All the while, employers will still not want people who were going to be off sick a lot, and they certainly would not want people with mental health problems. As for the withdrawal of PIP from those who were already in work or education, in order to find them work or education, where does one even begin?

Monday, 16 November 2026

The Next Prime Minister But Three

And as intended, here he is. The stocks are sold, the Press is squared, the middle class is quite prepared for the only thing even worse than being back in the European Union, namely being bound by its rules without having so much as the tiniest say over their content. We are to be a colony, a satrapy, a vassal state, back in the Customs Union and in Margaret Thatcher’s Single Market. If Switzerland is indeed to be the model, then we are even going to be joining the Schengen Area.

There will of course be no referendum. We are ruled by people to whom the vote is a nice thing to have, but who got their way by other means every day, so they did not really need it. If 60 per cent of the laws to which they were subject were made without the formal participation of their elected representatives, well, those were still going to be the laws that they themselves wanted, because that was how the world worked. We on the Left have been telling you this forever.

We were also the first in the field for material realism against gender self-identification, which David Cameron refused to rule out when a Commons Select Committee recommended it, which his flagship National Citizen Service implemented when allocating dormitories to teenagers, to which Theresa May and Boris Johnson were fiercely committed in office, and which grandees such as Dame Penny Mordaunt are not being required to recant in order to be selected as Conservative Party candidates for the next General Election.

There was no transmania when Andy Burnham was Health Secretary. For that, you had to wait for a Conservative Government that was really quite aggressive about it, complete with the then Jamie Wallis, Britain’s first and so far only transgender MP, though not Britain’s first transgender parliamentarian, since that was Nikki Sinclaire, elected as a Member of the European Parliament as long ago as 2009 under the Leadership of Nigel Farage, having twice sought election to the House of Commons under his banner after having left the Conservative Party.

Even Ann Widdecombe thought that men who had “undergone extensive surgery” should be sent to women’s prisons, while Russell Brand has split the gender-critical Establishment. Those who fled The Guardian maintain his guilt on the #MeToo and #BelieveAllWomen principles of old school feminism that would have required them to have done so even if he had been acquitted of all charges. Those who latched onto this issue when their new colleagues made that a good career move are part of the general veneration of Brand as a martyr of the Right. Both tendencies are wholly inadequate to the present task.

In 1530, England was an extravagantly Catholic country of many centuries’ standing. Yet by 1560, it had become the country that would define itself as fundamentally anti-Catholic for the next 400 years. Just as we are on the cusp of consigning Brexit to the same memory hole as the Commonwealth of England, making the EU as central to British identity as the Restoration made the monarchy to the England that had become a republic by parliamentary vote only 11 years earlier, so we are on the verge of taking the period from 16 April 2025 to some date in the near future and filing it alongside the reign of Mary I, except that that reign had made any practical difference to anyone.

In each case, that would be because the wrong people had been given responsibility for holding the line, people who never used to believe it, who still did not quite believe it, and who had no real idea why they should. We urgently need to move them aside in favour of those of us who always had, who truly did, and who knew exactly why.

Staggering

Talk about different times. On 2 November 2003, The Observer published an article by Miranda Sawyer calling for the age of consent to be lowered to 12; the following year, Sawyer made the same case in an hour-long documentary on Channel 4. On 9 November 2003, The Observer kindly published my letter arguing instead, as I argue again now after 23 years to the month, that it ought to be a criminal offence to engage in any sort of sexual activity with any person under the age of 18 who was more than two years younger than oneself, with a maximum sentence equal to twice the difference in age, and with the abolition of different rules for “positions of trust”.

We need to ban abortion and contraception for those under 18 at least without parental knowledge and consent, just as they thankfully cannot now be given puberty blockers. What sort of parent would want to put his underage daughter on the Pill? There is only one possible reason for doing so. The Thatcher Government secured a judicial fiat that, without bothering to ask Parliament, abolished the age of consent altogether. Gillick competence ought instead to be called Thatcher competence. The Major Government did write Thatcher competence into the Age of Legal Capacity (Scotland) Act 1991. But it is applied in Northern Ireland on no apparent authority. Even in England and Wales, it has never been subject to a parliamentary vote. Let there be one now.

We need to rule out the legal possibility of being a specifically sexual assailant below an age of consent that had been raised to 18, thereby correcting the anomaly that had existed since 2003. In that year, a male heterosexual age of consent of 16 was created by default due to political horse-trading among the feminist and gay groups around Harriet Harman, of all people, which insisted that both sexes and all acts be treated in exactly the same way. Yet the age of criminal responsibility remains 10, meaning that boys can be prosecuted for rape, itself significantly redefined in 2003, six years before they can legally have consensual sex. And they are. Indeed, boys who allege abuse by women are routinely accused of rape.

We need the replacement of the existing categories of sexual assault with aggravating circumstances to the general categories of offences against the person, such that the sentences could be doubled. There should be no anonymity either for adult defendants or for adult complainants. Either we have an open system of justice, or we do not. We need to specify that intoxication was a bar to sexual consent only insofar as it would have been a bar to driving. We need to end the blocking of progress into paid or voluntary work even though one had been acquitted. C5 notices should be outlawed. And we need to make it a criminal offence for anyone aged 21 or over to buy or sell sex, with equal sentencing on both sides. The Universal Basic Income, the Jobs Guarantee, and the dividends from public stakes in the FTSE 500 companies, distributed equally to everyone, would remove any conceivable excuse for prostituting oneself. That would include filmed or photographed prostitution, by banning certain categories of which we have demonstrated that the technology existed for a total ban.

There cannot be a “free” market in general, yet not in drugs, or prostitution, or pornography, or unrestricted alcohol, or unrestricted gambling. That is an important part of why there must not be a “free” market in general, which is a political choice, not a law of nature. Enacting and enforcing laws against drugs, prostitution and pornography, and regulating alcohol, tobacco and gambling, are clear examples of State intervention in, and regulation of, the economy. Radical change would be impossible if the workers, the youth and the poor were in a state of stupefaction. Contrived in the past, that baleful situation is being contrived again.

For example, to pay for the war, Ukraine is legalising the pornography that had been legally prohibited and practically unknown in the Soviet Union, but with which post-Soviet Russia was flooded to placate the young male population during the larceny of their country by means of the economic “shock therapy” that created today’s oligarchs, who were of course initially drawn from the nomenklatura, since where else might they have come from? “Sex work” has always been encouraged when the young men have needed to be stupefied, and it still is. The corporate capitalist pornogrification of our own society is no accident. In welcoming the endorsement of Bonnie Blue, Reform UK has picked its side, the same side as the Green Party on this as on the war.

So let no one accuse me of lining up with Lady Labour-Lanyard as she demanded, with the full power of the State, that digital ID be produced and her risk assessment carried out before anything more than holding hands would be permitted in the back row of the cinema. We know about her, anyway. We may be on the cusp of the formal disclosure that Britain was really run by state-employed or state-contracted middle-class women who thought that they were left-wing solely because they did not speak or dress like Hyacinth Bucket, and who had sex with each other and with teenage boys, often obtained commercially from the ever-larger desperate end of what was once the working class.

I have had my own dealings with such, I believe Russell Brand to be guilty of the offences of which he had been convicted, I await the prosecution of his unsuccessful accusers, and I note that if there was some problem with his barrister’s conduct of the case, then that did not prevent the jury from both convicting him unanimously and acquitting him unanimously. But he retains the absolute right to maintain his innocence, and his wife retains the absolute right to recount the contents of his conversations or correspondence with her. Even if he were not famous, then he could not now hope to be acquitted of anything due to another measure from 2003, the midpoint nadir of Tony Blair’s horrendous second term. In that year, the House of Commons approved the Iraq War. As the price of that war, it passed the hunting ban on the specific understanding that it would be a dead letter from the start, with neither the Prime Minister nor the Government Chief Whip voting in favour of it.

It abolished the protection against double jeopardy. It extended Police stop and search powers, and it allowed for persons who were merely “accompanying” the Police to participate actively in searches. It enabled the Police to issue conditional cautions that might still lead to a prosecution. It provided for leading City figures to be acquitted of fraud by judges sitting alone. It abolished the right of prisoners to apply to the High Court for bail, but it extended the right of the prosecution to appeal against the decision of a Magistrates’ Court to grant bail. It required that a list of defence witnesses, along with their names and addresses, be given for interview by the Police, and that the details of any defence expert witness instructed be given to the prosecution, whether or not that witness were then used. It empowered the prosecution to appeal against rulings of Crown Court judges that terminated cases or excluded evidence.

It introduced indeterminate sentence of “imprisonment for public protection” for offences that would otherwise carry a maximum sentence of 10 years. It made it a criminal offence for two people under the age of 16 to kiss each other; like the hunting ban, that was on the stated understanding that only a message was being sent, with absolutely no intention of any attempt at enforcement. And even as it restricted the cross-examination of prosecution witnesses on their own criminal records, it permitted the admission of hearsay, and of a defendant’s previous convictions and general “bad character”.

Brand was unable to find any character witnesses, but it would presumably not have mattered if he had had dozens. I had a parade of past and present members of both Houses of Parliament, senior Catholic and Anglican clergy, distinguished academics, prominent journalists, and others, including several of my supposed victims. But I was not allowed to call any of them in March 2020, when possibly any one, probably any two, and certainly any three would have guaranteed enough jurors to have prevented a conviction even by majority verdict. 

On 8 May 2025, I was declared “exonerated” by His Honour Judge Nathan Adams from the bench of Durham Crown Court. Exonerated of something very specific, but it makes all the difference. Though entirely unconnected to the charges, it had been admitted as “propensity” to secure my first conviction, despite there being absolutely no evidence at all to support the charges themselves and despite a previous trial's having collapsed a year earlier. Thanks to Blair’s abolition of the presumption of innocence, that conviction made and makes it effectively impossible for me ever to be acquitted of anything, even publishing blog posts that did not exist and which the only person claiming ever to have seen had first failed to present himself in court, and then been sacked from the Police because of his conduct of my case. I was still left with no option but to plead guilty in order to spare what little remained of my physical and mental health. But I didn’t do it. No one did it. As with the previous charges, it never happened.

No one, absolutely no one at all, has ever said to my face that they thought that I was guilty. I once again invite each and every Member of Parliament for the area covered by Durham County Council, each and every member of Durham County Council, each and every member of Lanchester Parish Council, each and every member of the Board of the Catholic Safeguarding Standards Agency, each and every member of the Hexham and Newcastle Diocesan Safeguarding Committee, each and every member of the Hexham and Newcastle Diocesan Safeguarding Team, and each and every bishop, priest or deacon of the Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle, to contact davidaslindsay@hotmail.com if they thought that I was factually or morally guilty of any criminal charge that had ever been brought against me. Not legally guilty. Factually and morally guilty, in that I had in fact committed any such offence. No name would be published except at the request of its bearer, but if anyone ever did get in touch, then the readers of this site would be the first to know. The current total is zero, as it has been since 28 July 2021.

Marmalade

Perhaps it has been the Pope's triumphant return to Peru that has put this in my mind, but to mark the approval of the housing of asylum seekers in Piddington, the King should rename the village "Paddington". Not everyone there will have voted Liberal Democrat, but Piddington is in a Lib Dem ward of a Lib Dem district, it is in a Lib Dem ward of a Lib Dem county, and it is in a Lib Dem parliamentary constituency. Not all individuals will have "voted for this", but the community certainly did. Just for somewhere else. Naturally.

In 1999, the Lib Dems offered a peerage to John Cleese, who now presents himself as Richard the Lionheart. But Monty Python's Life of Brian, still ubiquitous in school RE lessons, did more than any other single phenomenon to destroy a basically Christian culture in this and several other countries, to the point that most people would no longer get the jokes because those assumed mass familiarity with the Gospels.

Yet Cleese is providing security for Singh's Dining, the Sikh-owned London restaurant purportedly being targeted for not selling halal meat. Several other outlets on the same street are also non-halal, so there is obviously more to it. And the Far Right has apparently reverted to courting Sikhs, with Henry Nowak and Vikrum Digwa quietly forgotten. But all my life, I have been around brown people who thought that they would be all right if that lot came marching up their street. They would not. That lot literally cannot see the difference.

Lidl Britain

Paul Knaggs writes:

Governments don’t save their proudest announcements for Saturdays. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, put out his news on 14 November: the Jobs Guarantee will go nationwide from the end of the month, after trials in six areas with high unemployment. It came three days before Alan Milburn’s review into youth inactivity is due to land, and at the end of a week in which the papers reported that the review would recommend ending Personal Independence Payment and the health element of Universal Credit for 18 to 24-year-olds.

On paper, the scheme is simple. If you are 18 to 24 and have been on Universal Credit and out of work for 18 months, the state will find you a job and pay for it. That means up to 25 hours a week at the minimum wage for six months, with the employer’s National Insurance and minimum pension contributions included. From April, the qualifying period drops to 12 months. Ministers want 90,000 young people through the door by March 2029. The Office for National Statistics last counted 981,000 young people not in education, employment or training.

The case for it deserves a fair hearing, because it is not nothing. For a young person who has spent a year and a half being processed by a jobcentre, a wage is better than a sanction. A payslip is better than a warning letter. The scheme comes with support before and during the placement, and charities such as the YMCA have welcomed it. Labour has some history here, too. Gordon Brown’s Future Jobs Fund, set up in 2009, was scrapped by David Cameron as expensive and badly targeted. When the Department for Work and Pensions evaluated it in 2012, it found the opposite: a net gain to society of about £7,750 per participant. Subsidised jobs can work. The question is which kind of subsidised job, and who it is really for.

The Subsidy Behind the Shop Counter 

Jobs under the Future Jobs Fund had to carry an element of community benefit. Its independent evaluation complained that this made it hard to involve private firms. McFadden’s scheme has fixed that “problem” by going the other way. Its model isn’t Brown’s Future Jobs Fund. It is Rishi Sunak’s Kickstart: six months, 25 hours, minimum wage, young people on Universal Credit. When the National Audit Office looked at Kickstart in 2021, it found the department did not know whether the jobs were good ones or whether they would have existed anyway. Before the scheme had even begun, the DWP itself assumed only half the economic output would be genuinely additional, and it accepted the figure could be as low as 30 per cent.

This is the point Labour has chosen not to answer. Lidl and Boots already hire young people to stack shelves, staff tills and work in warehouses. That is their business. When the state pays every penny of a young worker’s wages, National Insurance and pension for six months, plus an onboarding payment of up to £250, one question decides whether the scheme is a public good or a gift. Would that shift have existed anyway? If it would, the taxpayer has not created a job. It has bought one that was already there and handed the saving to the employer.

The government will say there are safeguards, and there are. The guidance limits how many participants any one employer can host. But a limit on numbers is not a limit on churn. Nothing in the scheme obliges a firm to keep anyone on when the subsidy ends. Six months later the next cohort arrives, the cost to the firm is again nothing, and the young person who has just learned the job is back at the jobcentre with a reference and a gap where a career should be. Twenty-five hours a week at the minimum wage is part-time work, and the state is guaranteeing part-time, temporary work and calling it a guarantee.

A Paper Plaster Over a Structural Wound 

Ministers and their defenders will argue, with some sincerity, that long-term youth unemployment is a scar that deepens with every passing month. They will point out that 981,000 16-to-24-year-olds are currently not in education, employment or training, and that getting a young person out of the house, onto a rota and into the rhythm of a workplace is infinitely better than leaving them isolated on Universal Credit. A six-month placement at Boots or Cera, the argument goes, puts a line on a CV, builds confidence and gives a teenager a foot in the door that might otherwise stay locked. That is the best case for the scheme, and it deserves to be stated plainly. Nobody disputes that idleness corrodes a young life, or that a first job can be a turning point. 

Yet the argument collapses the moment you test the government’s own arithmetic against the scale of the crisis. Nearly one million young people are locked out of work and education right now, yet McFadden’s flagship scheme aims to place just 90,000 young people by March 2029. That is 90,000 temporary, part-time placements spread over nearly three years to answer an emergency affecting nearly a million lives. It is a paper plaster laid over a structural wound. In deindustrialised towns from Teesside to the Welsh valleys, the problem is not that young people lack the confidence to work a 25-hour minimum-wage shift. The problem is that half a century of economic abandonment stripped their towns of secure, well-paid industries and replaced them with low-wage service work and precarious rotas.

Now look at the second half of the policy, the half that wasn’t announced on a Saturday. According to reports from Milburn’s own interview with The Times, his review will propose that 18 to 24-year-olds, including existing claimants, lose PIP and the health element of Universal Credit. They would get a youth allowance at the standard Universal Credit rate instead, with separate provision for the extra costs of disability. Further reports say Downing Street is considering whether the same “participation first” principle should apply to adults over 25. None of this is policy yet. But the direction is plain, and the Jobs Guarantee has already been built to fit it. From April 2027 the scheme opens to young people on the health element of Universal Credit, on what ministers describe as a voluntary basis.

Today it is voluntary. The point of building the route is that it can later be made compulsory. That is an inference, and I mark it as one. But a government that is weighing up removing the health payment and a scheme that offers the health claimant a subsidised retail placement are two halves of the same design. The young disabled person gets the conditions. The employer gets the money. That is the shape of the whole thing. The carrot goes to the corporation and the stick goes to the claimant. Lidl is guaranteed a free worker. The 20-year-old with an anxiety disorder is guaranteed a review of whether he deserves his benefits.

The Brussels Squeeze

There is another pressure coming, and it arrives in Brussels on Friday. Andy Burnham goes to the UK-EU summit on 20 November hoping to agree a youth experience scheme, letting under-30s live, work and study on either side of the Channel. The government wants a cap of about 50,000 a year. Some EU states want up to 500,000, and others want no cap at all. The haggling is over how wide to open the door, not whether to open it. Many of those coming will be after the same entry-level jobs in shops, bars and hotels that the Jobs Guarantee is meant to open to our own long-term unemployed. Ministers will call it reciprocal: the borders are open both ways. So look at who actually goes through them. Young Britons do travel, but they go where English is spoken. In a single year, nearly 49,000 Britons went to Australia on youth mobility visas, about five for every Australian who came here. When Britain was in Erasmus, students from poorer homes made up barely a fifth of participants against almost a third of the student body.

Then add the classroom. In June, an independent inquiry found that just 36 per cent of white British pupils on free school meals get a grade 4 in English and maths GCSE, half the rate of pupils not on free school meals. GCSE language uptake is more than 20 points higher in the most affluent state schools, and schools serving poor communities find it hardest to hire language teachers. The kids on the council estates don’t speak French. Their German is left wanting, and Italian is something Bananarama once sang about Robert De Niro. A scheme that lets a graduate from Lyon with fluent English compete for a job in Leeds, while the lad from the estate can’t compete for one in Lyon, isn’t reciprocity. It is a one-way door with a two-way sign on it.

There is another way, and Britain once knew it well. For most of the last century, councils built homes with their own workforces, their direct labour organisations, and those yards trained apprentices who stayed for decades. Margaret Thatcher’s government forced them into competitive tendering from 1980, and they withered. If the state is going to pay 100 per cent of a young worker’s wages, it has every right to ask who owns what that worker produces. A public works guarantee would put young people to work building council homes, insulating cold houses, staffing care services and restoring parks, as full apprentices with a trade at the end of it. Then the public would own the result, not a supermarket’s shareholders.

Pat McFadden has spent the past year lecturing Labour MPs about fiscal discipline and demanding that the welfare bill be brought to heel. Yet when private corporations want their wage bills subsidised by the state, the Treasury purse strings loosen overnight. McFadden could start tomorrow with three changes. Firms taking subsidised workers should have to offer a permanent contract at the end or pay part of the subsidy back. Retention figures should be published employer by employer, so the public can see who keeps their young people and who simply rotates them. And no young person’s disability support should be cut on the strength of a placement scheme with no record yet of lasting jobs. A guarantee that ends after six months is not a guarantee. Lidl gets the guarantee. The young get the trial period.

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Threads In The Changing Tapestry

Doing a lot better than some of his old comrades, Kenan Malik writes:

“This bill is ethnocide.” “They are doing this to erase who we are.” “Should be imprisoned for his genocidal language.” “Absolute genocidal scumbag freak.” The rage of the online far right at a parliamentary attempt to allow black and Asian people to define themselves as English is almost comical in its hysteria.

Liberal Democrat MP Josh Babarinde, together with Labour’s David Lammy and Conservative James Cleverly, introduced a private members’ bill last week to ensure that “Black English” and “Asian English” were among the categories at the next census (currently only white people can mark themselves English). The bill was a performative exercise – it was never going to become law. But the very thought of parliamentarians arguing that whiteness was not a prerequisite for being English set the racists aflame, one nativist organisation even reporting Babarinde to the police for “hate speech”.

The online far right is a tiny cabal of noisemakers. The fact that some of the most bigoted people in society want to preserve a white-only cordon sanitaire around Englishness does not mean, though, that Babarinde’s bill, or the arguments of its proponents, are desirable. Englishness has complex roots and various modes of expression. It can refer to a people, a culture, a nationality or an identity to “a people, a culture, an ethnicity, a nationality or an identity. As in many such debates, the tussle over its meaning pits those who regard national belonging as a primordial, and usually ethnic, phenomenon against those who view it as a more modern development and not simply tied to ethnicity.

Some scholars trace the origins of Englishness to the early Middle Ages, many pointing to Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People, written around 731, as crystalising the idea. Others, such as historian and sociologist Krishan Kumar, argue that Bede was referring not to a unified people but to “still diverse groups of… distinct ethnicities”, and view English peoplehood as a more modern process. Of course, for some in this debate, Kumar’s very name invalidates his argument.

Whatever its origins, most reasonable people would accept that Englishness, like all identities, is not static and that its meaning has changed over time. From this perspective, recognising black and Asian people as English can be seen as the latest threads in the changing tapestry of English identity. There is a distinction, though, between acknowledging a more inclusive vision of Englishness and establishing “white”, “black” and “Asian” as distinct ways of being English. Pluralising Englishness by viewing it through multiple racial lenses rather than a single one is no advance.

We usually think about pluralism as a liberal concept. It is, though, an ambiguous term, its roots running back to conservative hostility to the universalist values that grew out of the Enlightenment. It has since become appropriated, in different ways, by both left and right. In the postwar years, disillusioned by ideas of Enlightenment universalism, many on the left embraced pluralism as a means of understanding human differences, as a basis for social policy, and as an antidote to racism. The far right seized upon pluralism, too, but for the opposite reason - as a means of reviving racial thought that had been shredded by the experience of Nazism and the Holocaust. “The true wealth of the world is first and foremost the diversity of its cultures and peoples.”

That might have come from the pen of a liberal multiculturalist. It was in fact written by the French philosopher Alain de Benoist, a founder of the Nouvelle Droite. To revive the fortunes of the far right, Benoist reworked culture as a synonym for race. Every culture, he insisted, was anchored to a geographic location and could be possessed only by those descended from the original inhabitants. As carriers of alien cultures and histories, immigrants must always remain outsiders. Such “ethnopluralism” links a sense of belonging to intolerance towards those deemed not to belong. It has become absorbed by the far right, and indeed, by sections of the not-so-far right. It lies at the heart of current debates about Englishness.

Challenging such arguments requires us not to racialise identity in a different way but to challenge the very process of racialisation. To make census definitions of Englishness more inclusive, we need to strip out the racial category that now delimits it – “white English” – rather than add new racial boxes into which to pigeonhole people. Part of the problem lies in the messiness of census categories, and the emphasis on ethnicity over other forms of social identities. In this, the census mirrors the wider ways in which, as individuals, institutions and policymakers, we think about social affiliation, ways that often distort our understanding.

Consider education. For years, policymakers were so obsessed with ethnicity that they ignored their own data showing the greater significance of class in shaping pupils’ performance. More recently, as questions of class have come to the fore, class itself has become racialised. In discussions of issues faced by white working-class children, their whiteness has often seemed to matter more than their class location. There has equally been a failure to recognise that patterns of attainment displayed by minority pupils may have less to do with their ethnicity than with their class. The very categories used to make sense of the world too often serve to obscure reality.

The bigotry of the online far right expresses in an extreme fashion many of the distortions that bedevil our thinking about identity and belonging. Beyond dismantling their racist arguments, we need a wider debate about the social categories we use and the ways in which they can warp, rather than clarify, our understanding of the world.

As Usual?


The Krakow murderer is dead, and there is no need to try him. So I can write freely about the case – as I could not do if it had recently happened here. The point I wish to make is very simple. The repeated claims by politicians, police officers and security ‘experts’ that mass killers are politically motivated are bilge. Michal Oksinski was crazy, and there is (if you look) evidence that he is crazy because he used marijuana. As usual.

These people are stark mad. They mouth slogans but have no plan and belong to no real organisation. No cause, however vile, could possibly benefit because one of its followers randomly butchers a large number of innocent people and is then predictably killed by the police. Who is going to rally to what bloody flag, as a result of that? Nobody, ever.

Oksinski began his murders by slaughtering his mother, father and sister in their beds, a detail which media organisations were strangely slow to publish. Poland’s strong Right-wing opposition party took offence when interior minister Marcin Kierwinski pronounced that Oksinski had been influenced by far-Right ideology. They called it a ‘blatant lie’.

Kryminopedia, a popular Polish true-crime YouTube channel, interviewed a former acquaintance of the killer. He recalled that the teenage group they both belonged to used marijuana and other drugs – as if that is a surprise. Perhaps, sometime around 2056, everyone will put two and two together. In the meantime, it will keep happening, and the authorities will keep missing the point.

There cannot be a “free” market in general, yet not in drugs, or prostitution, or pornography, or unrestricted alcohol, or unrestricted gambling. That is an important part of why there must not be a “free” market in general, which is a political choice, not a law of nature. Enacting and enforcing laws against drugs, prostitution and pornography, and regulating alcohol, tobacco and gambling, are clear examples of State intervention in, and regulation of, the economy. Radical change would be impossible if the workers, the youth and the poor were in a state of stupefaction. Contrived in the past, that baleful situation is being contrived again today.

We need a single category of illegal drug, including cannabis, with a crackdown on possession, including a mandatory sentence of two years for a first offence, three years for a second offence, four years for a third offence, and so on. No prison sentence should include the possibility of release in less than 12 months; in that case, then your crime was not bad enough to warrant imprisonment, which the possession of drugs is. We need to restore the specific criminal offence of allowing one’s premises to be used for illegal drug purposes. And we need Hitchens’s The War We Never Fought to be taught in schools.

Why not? We are within sight of effectively raising the age of consent to 18, so anything is possible. And Russell Brand’s trouble was more drugs than anything else, making this a moment not to be missed.