Monday, 16 November 2026

Marmelade

Perhaps it has been the Pope's triumphant return to Peru that has put this in my mind, but to mark the approval of the housing of asylum seekers in Piddington, the King should rename the village "Paddington". Not everyone there will have voted Liberal Democrat, but Piddington is in a Lib Dem ward of a Lib Dem district, it is in a Lib Dem ward of a Lib Dem county, and it is in a Lib Dem parliamentary constituency. Not all individuals will have "voted for this", but the community certainly did. Just for somewhere else. Naturally.

In 1999, the Lib Dems offered a peerage to John Cleese, who now presents himself as Richard the Lionheart. But Monty Python's Life of Brian, still ubiquitous in school RE lessons, did more than any other single phenomenon to destroy a basically Christian culture in this and several other countries, to the point that most people would no longer get the jokes because those assumed mass familiarity with the Gospels.

Yet Cleese is providing security for Singh's Dining, the Sikh-owned London restaurant purportedly being targeted for not selling halal meat. Several other outlets on the same street are also non-halal, so there is obviously more to it. And the Far Right has apparently reverted to courting Sikhs, with Henry Nowak and Vikrum Digwa quietly forgotten. But all my life, I have been around brown people who thought that they would be all right if that lot came marching up their street. They would not. That lot literally cannot see the difference.

Lidl Britain

Paul Knaggs writes:

Governments don’t save their proudest announcements for Saturdays. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, put out his news on 14 November: the Jobs Guarantee will go nationwide from the end of the month, after trials in six areas with high unemployment. It came three days before Alan Milburn’s review into youth inactivity is due to land, and at the end of a week in which the papers reported that the review would recommend ending Personal Independence Payment and the health element of Universal Credit for 18 to 24-year-olds.

On paper, the scheme is simple. If you are 18 to 24 and have been on Universal Credit and out of work for 18 months, the state will find you a job and pay for it. That means up to 25 hours a week at the minimum wage for six months, with the employer’s National Insurance and minimum pension contributions included. From April, the qualifying period drops to 12 months. Ministers want 90,000 young people through the door by March 2029. The Office for National Statistics last counted 981,000 young people not in education, employment or training.

The case for it deserves a fair hearing, because it is not nothing. For a young person who has spent a year and a half being processed by a jobcentre, a wage is better than a sanction. A payslip is better than a warning letter. The scheme comes with support before and during the placement, and charities such as the YMCA have welcomed it. Labour has some history here, too. Gordon Brown’s Future Jobs Fund, set up in 2009, was scrapped by David Cameron as expensive and badly targeted. When the Department for Work and Pensions evaluated it in 2012, it found the opposite: a net gain to society of about £7,750 per participant. Subsidised jobs can work. The question is which kind of subsidised job, and who it is really for.

The Subsidy Behind the Shop Counter 

Jobs under the Future Jobs Fund had to carry an element of community benefit. Its independent evaluation complained that this made it hard to involve private firms. McFadden’s scheme has fixed that “problem” by going the other way. Its model isn’t Brown’s Future Jobs Fund. It is Rishi Sunak’s Kickstart: six months, 25 hours, minimum wage, young people on Universal Credit. When the National Audit Office looked at Kickstart in 2021, it found the department did not know whether the jobs were good ones or whether they would have existed anyway. Before the scheme had even begun, the DWP itself assumed only half the economic output would be genuinely additional, and it accepted the figure could be as low as 30 per cent.

This is the point Labour has chosen not to answer. Lidl and Boots already hire young people to stack shelves, staff tills and work in warehouses. That is their business. When the state pays every penny of a young worker’s wages, National Insurance and pension for six months, plus an onboarding payment of up to £250, one question decides whether the scheme is a public good or a gift. Would that shift have existed anyway? If it would, the taxpayer has not created a job. It has bought one that was already there and handed the saving to the employer.

The government will say there are safeguards, and there are. The guidance limits how many participants any one employer can host. But a limit on numbers is not a limit on churn. Nothing in the scheme obliges a firm to keep anyone on when the subsidy ends. Six months later the next cohort arrives, the cost to the firm is again nothing, and the young person who has just learned the job is back at the jobcentre with a reference and a gap where a career should be. Twenty-five hours a week at the minimum wage is part-time work, and the state is guaranteeing part-time, temporary work and calling it a guarantee.

A Paper Plaster Over a Structural Wound 

Ministers and their defenders will argue, with some sincerity, that long-term youth unemployment is a scar that deepens with every passing month. They will point out that 981,000 16-to-24-year-olds are currently not in education, employment or training, and that getting a young person out of the house, onto a rota and into the rhythm of a workplace is infinitely better than leaving them isolated on Universal Credit. A six-month placement at Boots or Cera, the argument goes, puts a line on a CV, builds confidence and gives a teenager a foot in the door that might otherwise stay locked. That is the best case for the scheme, and it deserves to be stated plainly. Nobody disputes that idleness corrodes a young life, or that a first job can be a turning point. 

Yet the argument collapses the moment you test the government’s own arithmetic against the scale of the crisis. Nearly one million young people are locked out of work and education right now, yet McFadden’s flagship scheme aims to place just 90,000 young people by March 2029. That is 90,000 temporary, part-time placements spread over nearly three years to answer an emergency affecting nearly a million lives. It is a paper plaster laid over a structural wound. In deindustrialised towns from Teesside to the Welsh valleys, the problem is not that young people lack the confidence to work a 25-hour minimum-wage shift. The problem is that half a century of economic abandonment stripped their towns of secure, well-paid industries and replaced them with low-wage service work and precarious rotas.

Now look at the second half of the policy, the half that wasn’t announced on a Saturday. According to reports from Milburn’s own interview with The Times, his review will propose that 18 to 24-year-olds, including existing claimants, lose PIP and the health element of Universal Credit. They would get a youth allowance at the standard Universal Credit rate instead, with separate provision for the extra costs of disability. Further reports say Downing Street is considering whether the same “participation first” principle should apply to adults over 25. None of this is policy yet. But the direction is plain, and the Jobs Guarantee has already been built to fit it. From April 2027 the scheme opens to young people on the health element of Universal Credit, on what ministers describe as a voluntary basis.

Today it is voluntary. The point of building the route is that it can later be made compulsory. That is an inference, and I mark it as one. But a government that is weighing up removing the health payment and a scheme that offers the health claimant a subsidised retail placement are two halves of the same design. The young disabled person gets the conditions. The employer gets the money. That is the shape of the whole thing. The carrot goes to the corporation and the stick goes to the claimant. Lidl is guaranteed a free worker. The 20-year-old with an anxiety disorder is guaranteed a review of whether he deserves his benefits.

The Brussels Squeeze

There is another pressure coming, and it arrives in Brussels on Friday. Andy Burnham goes to the UK-EU summit on 20 November hoping to agree a youth experience scheme, letting under-30s live, work and study on either side of the Channel. The government wants a cap of about 50,000 a year. Some EU states want up to 500,000, and others want no cap at all. The haggling is over how wide to open the door, not whether to open it. Many of those coming will be after the same entry-level jobs in shops, bars and hotels that the Jobs Guarantee is meant to open to our own long-term unemployed. Ministers will call it reciprocal: the borders are open both ways. So look at who actually goes through them. Young Britons do travel, but they go where English is spoken. In a single year, nearly 49,000 Britons went to Australia on youth mobility visas, about five for every Australian who came here. When Britain was in Erasmus, students from poorer homes made up barely a fifth of participants against almost a third of the student body.

Then add the classroom. In June, an independent inquiry found that just 36 per cent of white British pupils on free school meals get a grade 4 in English and maths GCSE, half the rate of pupils not on free school meals. GCSE language uptake is more than 20 points higher in the most affluent state schools, and schools serving poor communities find it hardest to hire language teachers. The kids on the council estates don’t speak French. Their German is left wanting, and Italian is something Bananarama once sang about Robert De Niro. A scheme that lets a graduate from Lyon with fluent English compete for a job in Leeds, while the lad from the estate can’t compete for one in Lyon, isn’t reciprocity. It is a one-way door with a two-way sign on it.

There is another way, and Britain once knew it well. For most of the last century, councils built homes with their own workforces, their direct labour organisations, and those yards trained apprentices who stayed for decades. Margaret Thatcher’s government forced them into competitive tendering from 1980, and they withered. If the state is going to pay 100 per cent of a young worker’s wages, it has every right to ask who owns what that worker produces. A public works guarantee would put young people to work building council homes, insulating cold houses, staffing care services and restoring parks, as full apprentices with a trade at the end of it. Then the public would own the result, not a supermarket’s shareholders.

Pat McFadden has spent the past year lecturing Labour MPs about fiscal discipline and demanding that the welfare bill be brought to heel. Yet when private corporations want their wage bills subsidised by the state, the Treasury purse strings loosen overnight. McFadden could start tomorrow with three changes. Firms taking subsidised workers should have to offer a permanent contract at the end or pay part of the subsidy back. Retention figures should be published employer by employer, so the public can see who keeps their young people and who simply rotates them. And no young person’s disability support should be cut on the strength of a placement scheme with no record yet of lasting jobs. A guarantee that ends after six months is not a guarantee. Lidl gets the guarantee. The young get the trial period.

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Threads In The Changing Tapestry

Doing a lot better than some of his old comrades, Kenan Malik writes:

“This bill is ethnocide.” “They are doing this to erase who we are.” “Should be imprisoned for his genocidal language.” “Absolute genocidal scumbag freak.” The rage of the online far right at a parliamentary attempt to allow black and Asian people to define themselves as English is almost comical in its hysteria.

Liberal Democrat MP Josh Babarinde, together with Labour’s David Lammy and Conservative James Cleverly, introduced a private members’ bill last week to ensure that “Black English” and “Asian English” were among the categories at the next census (currently only white people can mark themselves English). The bill was a performative exercise – it was never going to become law. But the very thought of parliamentarians arguing that whiteness was not a prerequisite for being English set the racists aflame, one nativist organisation even reporting Babarinde to the police for “hate speech”.

The online far right is a tiny cabal of noisemakers. The fact that some of the most bigoted people in society want to preserve a white-only cordon sanitaire around Englishness does not mean, though, that Babarinde’s bill, or the arguments of its proponents, are desirable. Englishness has complex roots and various modes of expression. It can refer to a people, a culture, a nationality or an identity to “a people, a culture, an ethnicity, a nationality or an identity. As in many such debates, the tussle over its meaning pits those who regard national belonging as a primordial, and usually ethnic, phenomenon against those who view it as a more modern development and not simply tied to ethnicity.

Some scholars trace the origins of Englishness to the early Middle Ages, many pointing to Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People, written around 731, as crystalising the idea. Others, such as historian and sociologist Krishan Kumar, argue that Bede was referring not to a unified people but to “still diverse groups of… distinct ethnicities”, and view English peoplehood as a more modern process. Of course, for some in this debate, Kumar’s very name invalidates his argument.

Whatever its origins, most reasonable people would accept that Englishness, like all identities, is not static and that its meaning has changed over time. From this perspective, recognising black and Asian people as English can be seen as the latest threads in the changing tapestry of English identity. There is a distinction, though, between acknowledging a more inclusive vision of Englishness and establishing “white”, “black” and “Asian” as distinct ways of being English. Pluralising Englishness by viewing it through multiple racial lenses rather than a single one is no advance.

We usually think about pluralism as a liberal concept. It is, though, an ambiguous term, its roots running back to conservative hostility to the universalist values that grew out of the Enlightenment. It has since become appropriated, in different ways, by both left and right. In the postwar years, disillusioned by ideas of Enlightenment universalism, many on the left embraced pluralism as a means of understanding human differences, as a basis for social policy, and as an antidote to racism. The far right seized upon pluralism, too, but for the opposite reason - as a means of reviving racial thought that had been shredded by the experience of Nazism and the Holocaust. “The true wealth of the world is first and foremost the diversity of its cultures and peoples.”

That might have come from the pen of a liberal multiculturalist. It was in fact written by the French philosopher Alain de Benoist, a founder of the Nouvelle Droite. To revive the fortunes of the far right, Benoist reworked culture as a synonym for race. Every culture, he insisted, was anchored to a geographic location and could be possessed only by those descended from the original inhabitants. As carriers of alien cultures and histories, immigrants must always remain outsiders. Such “ethnopluralism” links a sense of belonging to intolerance towards those deemed not to belong. It has become absorbed by the far right, and indeed, by sections of the not-so-far right. It lies at the heart of current debates about Englishness.

Challenging such arguments requires us not to racialise identity in a different way but to challenge the very process of racialisation. To make census definitions of Englishness more inclusive, we need to strip out the racial category that now delimits it – “white English” – rather than add new racial boxes into which to pigeonhole people. Part of the problem lies in the messiness of census categories, and the emphasis on ethnicity over other forms of social identities. In this, the census mirrors the wider ways in which, as individuals, institutions and policymakers, we think about social affiliation, ways that often distort our understanding.

Consider education. For years, policymakers were so obsessed with ethnicity that they ignored their own data showing the greater significance of class in shaping pupils’ performance. More recently, as questions of class have come to the fore, class itself has become racialised. In discussions of issues faced by white working-class children, their whiteness has often seemed to matter more than their class location. There has equally been a failure to recognise that patterns of attainment displayed by minority pupils may have less to do with their ethnicity than with their class. The very categories used to make sense of the world too often serve to obscure reality.

The bigotry of the online far right expresses in an extreme fashion many of the distortions that bedevil our thinking about identity and belonging. Beyond dismantling their racist arguments, we need a wider debate about the social categories we use and the ways in which they can warp, rather than clarify, our understanding of the world.

As Usual?


The Krakow murderer is dead, and there is no need to try him. So I can write freely about the case – as I could not do if it had recently happened here. The point I wish to make is very simple. The repeated claims by politicians, police officers and security ‘experts’ that mass killers are politically motivated are bilge. Michal Oksinski was crazy, and there is (if you look) evidence that he is crazy because he used marijuana. As usual.

These people are stark mad. They mouth slogans but have no plan and belong to no real organisation. No cause, however vile, could possibly benefit because one of its followers randomly butchers a large number of innocent people and is then predictably killed by the police. Who is going to rally to what bloody flag, as a result of that? Nobody, ever.

Oksinski began his murders by slaughtering his mother, father and sister in their beds, a detail which media organisations were strangely slow to publish. Poland’s strong Right-wing opposition party took offence when interior minister Marcin Kierwinski pronounced that Oksinski had been influenced by far-Right ideology. They called it a ‘blatant lie’.

Kryminopedia, a popular Polish true-crime YouTube channel, interviewed a former acquaintance of the killer. He recalled that the teenage group they both belonged to used marijuana and other drugs – as if that is a surprise. Perhaps, sometime around 2056, everyone will put two and two together. In the meantime, it will keep happening, and the authorities will keep missing the point.

There cannot be a “free” market in general, yet not in drugs, or prostitution, or pornography, or unrestricted alcohol, or unrestricted gambling. That is an important part of why there must not be a “free” market in general, which is a political choice, not a law of nature. Enacting and enforcing laws against drugs, prostitution and pornography, and regulating alcohol, tobacco and gambling, are clear examples of State intervention in, and regulation of, the economy. Radical change would be impossible if the workers, the youth and the poor were in a state of stupefaction. Contrived in the past, that baleful situation is being contrived again today.

We need a single category of illegal drug, including cannabis, with a crackdown on possession, including a mandatory sentence of two years for a first offence, three years for a second offence, four years for a third offence, and so on. No prison sentence should include the possibility of release in less than 12 months; in that case, then your crime was not bad enough to warrant imprisonment, which the possession of drugs is. We need to restore the specific criminal offence of allowing one’s premises to be used for illegal drug purposes. And we need Hitchens’s The War We Never Fought to be taught in schools.

Why not? We are within sight of effectively raising the age of consent to 18, so anything is possible. And Russell Brand’s trouble was more drugs than anything else, making this a moment not to be missed.

Spanish Practices

I do not know, or care to know, the meaning of “suicidal empathy”, but it sounds very much like our arming of the Saudi Arabia that inspired, funded and directed jihadi cells in our own countries. Therefore, another example would be our indulgence of Svoboda, Pravy Sektor, the National Corps, C14, the Azov Brigade, the Aidar Battalion, the Donbas Battalion, the Dnipro-1 Battalion, the Dnipro-2 Battalion, the Kraken Regiment, and all the rest of them, including the Freedom of Russia Legion and the Russian Volunteer Corps. 

In Spain, 14 members of Núcleo Nacional have just been arrested for planning an armed insurrection, including their spokeswoman Isabel Peralta, who had already been deported from Germany for displaying the Swastika, and whose home was found to contain assault rifles, pistols, a huge amount of ammunition, and a bust of Hitler, dressed as whom the organisation sells a Hello Kitty. Some members of Núcleo Nacional are as young as 14, and it trains with the Azov Brigade in the Ukraine that Pedro Sánchez backs to the hilt.

But Núcleo Nacional supports Vox, which merely denies a formal organisational relationship, and without which the Partido Popular, itself the successor of the Alianza Popular that seven of Franco’s Ministers had founded to guard his legacy, would be unable to form a government after the General Election on 29 November. Therefore, dreadful though Sánchez is in very many ways, he is just going to have to do, even in the light of that of which Craig Murray writes:

The Trump regime’s extradition case against Fergie Chambers is so thin, that the US Justice Department did not even turn up to try to enforce it. At the Assange extradition hearings there were always a minimum of two Justice Department officials, every day, seated behind the British Home Secretary’s legal team, exchanging notes and whispers.

Extradition requests are processed through the courts by the host country’s prosecuting authorities, but I have never before seen a high profile extradition case there the extraditing country did not bother to turn up. There was nobody from the US Justice Department in court, nobody from the FBI who are requesting the extradition, and not even a lowly Third Secretary from the Embassy to take notes on who was there and what was happening.

In truth there is no case. The allegations – of riot, incitement to riot, and money laundering – are unsupported by any kind of coherent narrative. The problem is, in some ways that does not matter. Extradition is a technical process, where the justiciary in one country request the justiciary in another to send a suspect for trial. The potentially extraditing country assesses whether the request is technically correct and in proper form, and if so, agrees to extradition.

The process is provided in the extradition agreement between the two states. Here is a crucial point: the extraditing country is not judging innocence or guilt, or even the weight of evidence. It is just checking the request is from the proper state authorities in the proper form. It is a box-checking exercise, and notoriously difficult to stop.

Here is your second crucial point. Courts do not have the final say. The court can stop an extradition as not in the proper form and thus transgressing the rights of an individual. A court can alternatively permit an extradition. But a court cannot order an extradition to happen. Extraditions are a government to government matter, governed by international agreement that stands outside domestic law. So in the UK, the courts allowed the US extradition request for Gary MacKinnon, but Home Secretary Theresa May did not action it, on human rights and health grounds.

In Spain this final decision rests, should the Court rule extradition legal, not with a single minister but formally with the Council of Ministers. That body already took the decision to allow the extradition to proceed to the courts. Progressive opinion in Spain was outraged and to those of us outside who had viewed Sanchez as one of the islands of pro-Palestinian statesmanship, it came as an alarming lesson in the exercise of American and Israeli power.

So here we were at the Audiencia Nacional, Spain’s High Court, for the extradition hearing. Madrid is perhaps the most spectacular of old Imperial capitals, with the sheer mass of its governing buildings, the depth and intricacy of its stone carving, the extraordinary effusions of unabashed baroque around every corner, and the glory of its art collections, parks and fountains. You can see where all that plundered gold went.

You would expect the High Court to be set in one of those magnificent buildings, all looming capitals, dark tropical hardwoods, blackened oil paintings and gilded armorial crests. But it is not. It is set in dystopian future Hell. You walk past some police check points into an open courtyard, in the middle of which sits a low brick of a building made of steel and armoured glass. This is the entrance to the Audiencia Nacional. It is not connected to anything, it stands alone, looking like a greenhouse designed to ensure the tomatoes survive thermonuclear war.

You enter at the narrow end, and are processed through security screening and identity checks. These are very slow. Spain is one of those nations where, as soon as you give someone a police uniform or a jacket with “seguridad” written on the back, they take it as part of their everyday duty to be as hostile as possible to members of the public, with bonus points for intimidation. Once processed through here, you immediately face a lift which goes down below ground level. You have no option to go up, indeed there is no floor above you. You can only go down into the windowless underground bunker that is Spain’s High Court. Why Spain’s High Court is a windowless bunker I cannot tell you.

It is not only windowless, it is all white. Everything is white. You wait on white benches in a white corridor, lit with harsh white light. When you enter the courtroom through a white door, the judges are seated behind white desks on a white dais. The lawyers’ white desks are at right angles to the judges, on the same level – prosecution to the judges’ left and defence to the right. Then on the lower level stretch lines of white desks for the rest of the legal teams, not used on this occasion, still at right angles to the judges. Then you come to the rows of public benches facing the judges. These benches are formed from pressed metal and are completely white. They are also completely comfortless, with a metal ridged seat area and hard metal back. It is the aesthetic of oppression: clinical, clean, comfortless, and utterly without soul.

In the middle of the front row of benches sat Fergie Chambers, sporting an impressive Freddie Mercury moustache, a solitary interpreter next to him. He was neatly and casually dressed. Behind him two rows were kept empty. Then we had two rows of the public, including me, and a further half row of the public behind, about 18 of the public in total – all of them connected to Chambers’s support and including Barry Pollack, his US lawyer. At the back were a further two empty rows. We had been told the public gallery would be restricted to 14 people. In the event a few more were allowed, but another couple of dozen could have easily been accommodated. I may have helped boost the number slightly, as the front security check asked me if I was a journalist and I said “no, retired Ambassador”. I may have said the “retired” rather quietly.

There was a separate room for journalists to watch on screen. I do not know if any came. There are permanent crews outside the High Court from TV España and TV Madrid, but they quite openly told us that they were under instruction not to cover the case. The unnecessary restriction of the public entering the “public galleries” for cases involving Palestine is a worldwide phenomenon. In the UK Supreme Court, zero public were allowed in that actual courtroom for the Palestine Action hearing. It is of course part of the theatre of “counter-terrorism”, but it is also a small symptom of authoritarian governments increasingly becoming afraid of their own people.

The American extradition request is on the basis of a sealed criminal complaint sworn by a single FBI agent, not a grand-jury indictment. No formal charges have been preferred; the extradition request itself states that an indictment will be sought from a grand jury only if Spain surrenders Chambers. The complaint alleges three offences: riot, conspiracy to riot, and international money laundering. The riot offences relate to Palestine Action protests against Elbit, the Israeli weapons manufacturer, at their factories in New Hampshire, and Massachusetts. Chambers is alleged to have organised and financed the “riot”, to have taken part and to have paid bail for those arrested. The money laundering concerns approximately $7.2–7.5 million transferred in ten payments from a US bank account to accounts in Tunisia between March 2024 and April 2025, while Chambers was living there. The complaint alleges the funds were intended to provide material support to Hamas or associated organisations.

Spanish prosecutors have supported the extradition request, characterising the alleged conduct as corresponding to offences under Spanish law (including terrorist financing and public disorder). As always, you need to go to the text of the extradition treaty to understand what is now happening. Exactly as with the Julian Assange case, the first and obvious point is the bar on political extradition. The Treaty says this:



Please note it is for the Spanish authorities – not necessarily judicial authorities – to decide whether the request is political, and this is the point on which it is shocking that Sanchez’s Cabinet allowed it to go ahead. There is a further key point here. The extradition treaty excludes from political offences, offences involving weapons and it states that explosive or incendiary device charges make an offence non-political:


This is the purpose of the specific criminal complaint that Fergie Chambers purchased the smoke bombs for the Elbit protest, which the US and Spanish prosecutors are attempting to characterise as explosive or incendiary devices for the purpose of obviating the political exclusion. We will return to this point in the context of mistranslations. There is a strong echo here of the UK’s proscription of Palestine Action. One of the three incidents the Home Office cited as having “reached the level of terrorism” was the 2022 action at the Thales factory in Glasgow. The designation rested essentially on the use of smoke bombs, described as pyrotechnics, in the Sheriff’s florid sentencing remarks, thrown near staff and therefore not “non-violent.”

Now, I am old and grumpy, and there are some features of modern protest that I dislike. One is talentless “samba bands” drumming. Another is smoke flares. But smoke flares are common features of protests and football crowds, yet are now being characterised, on both sides of the Atlantic, as terrorist. I started this article by explaining that extradition requests are essentially technical. It is here that this one should fail. The extradition treaty could not possibly be clearer that the extradition request must come from a judge or judicial official. As it starts at paragraph X (D):


This condition is simply not met. There is no warrant from a judge or judicial authority. There is a criminal complaint from an FBI agent and a covering letter from the Attorney-General of New Hampshire. There has been no grand jury, no judge has ever seen the matter, and there are no charges. Yet again I must return to the Assange experience. The exercise of power in a state has nothing to do with justice. In the Assange case, the UK Supreme Court in 2012 ruled that in the original Swedish complaint “judicial authority” did not mean “judicial authority” and could in fact include a prosecutor.

They based this decision on preferring – for the only time I ever saw in my diplomatic experience – the French text of the EU arrest warrant treaty to the English text. But the British diplomats who agreed the treaty would have been working from the English text, as would the Ministers who signed up to it and the parliament it was lain before. The Supreme Court then ruled that “autorité judiciaire” in French does include prosecutors – a very arguable contention.

States are corrupt. Being undeniably right does not always win in court. We will see whether the Spanish judiciary are less corrupt than their English cousins. However the judges have less wiggle room than was available in the UK, because the Spanish law 4/1985 incorporates the full text of the extradition treaty into Spanish domestic law. The British government argued successfully in the Assange case that the provisions of the UK/US Extradition Treaty had no legal effect in the UK. That argument is not open in Spain. I do not see how they escape the “judicial authority” point. There are other technical points about the American documentation, which in a tick box exercise fails to tick any of the requisite boxes. There are discrepancies in dates. Key documents are missing, with only their cover sheets provided.

We now come to the mistranslations. The US government produced a Spanish translation of the complaint which consistently exaggerates the alleged criminal behaviour, in a way apparently designed to increase the chances of extradition. To give examples, “direct action” is translated as “direct violence”. The phrase “multiple direct action events occurred at Elbit facilities” became “multiple direct violence events occurred at Elbit facilities” when rendered in Spanish.

In English “the three [activists] caused significant damage to the building” becomes in Spanish “three fires caused significant damage to the building”. The English original refers to activists for whom Fergie Chambers provided bail. It is not easy to see how the completely unfounded insertion of “fires” occurs accidentally. I know translation is a difficult art, but remember that arson is one of the activities that negates the political exclusion.

Other than this “mistranslation”, there is no allegation there were any fires and there are no reports of fires at Elbit premises in the USA. In similar vein, in various places “activate” or “set off” smoke bombs is translated into Spanish as “detonate” smoke bombs. To detonate is, neither in English nor Spanish, the word naturally used with a smoke bomb, and the changed meaning is obvious. As a final example, the English word “trespass” is translated as the Spanish word for “burglary”, a very different level of offence.

The mistranslation saga plays into the final technical requirement for extradition which I will bring to your attention, that the alleged offence must be a crime in both the United States and Spain, punishable by more than one year in jail. The US extradition request in fact fails to cite specific offences, under which law, and what the penalties are. But all these are specific requirements of the Treaty. Remarkably the Spanish prosecutors have filled the gap by extrapolating from the US request named Spanish equivalent charges – some of which hinge on those mistranslations. The alleged “money laundering” complaint by the USA does not in fact specify transfer to finance terrorist organisations, other than as an avenue of investigation. The Spanish prosecutor has added terrorist financing as a specific charge.

Now that I have outlined the issues at hand, let us return to the court. The proceeding opened with the case for the defence being put by Josep Riba. He spoke authoritatively and at length, and appeared to have the full attention of the judges, who leaned forward diligently and took extensive notes. He was not significantly interrupted, as indeed were none of the lawyers. Riba spoke in Spanish. I had no access to interpretation and I am not going to pretend to you to have understood everything he said. An important point he made was that the extradition is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, on grounds both of freedom of speech and assembly, and of due process. At the end of his presentation he requested the court to hear evidence from Fergie Chambers. The judge responded that this court was not finding innocence or guilt, and should not hear evidence of the truth or otherwise of the charges. Riba replied that Chambers’s testimony went to the question of whether the extradition request was “manifestly ill-founded”, under Article X (D) of the extradition treaty: 

The requested Party may refuse the extradition request if an examination of the case in question shows that the warrant is manifestly ill-founded.

It would also go to the question of political motivation. The judge accepted this, and Riba began the cross-examination of Chambers, with consecutive translation both ways. It was good to hear Fergie Chambers speak. His appearance, and perhaps his cultivated image, is against him.




If you Google images of him, Fergie Chambers looks like what a right-wing reactionary would imagine a domestic terrorist looks like. On top of which he has the toned body and extensive tattooing of an MMA fighter. Of course, if you investigate what Chambers’s tattoos actually say or represent, they reveal something very different. But I wonder whether someone in the Trump regime decided to go after Chambers because of his image, rather than anything he had actually done.

I had never met Fergie Chambers. Indeed until last week, I had hardly heard of him. From seeing him online, I expected him to sound abrasive, even rough. Instead what came over was a gentle and thoughtful man with a soft, calm voice. He is obviously educated, intellectual, proceeds with thought and care, and has a wide but applied social conscience. He also plainly loves his family, and is vulnerable. You can easily find the video of his interrogation online; but my written distillation of it perhaps captures the essence.

The prosecution was given the first opportunity to question Fergie Chambers but declined to do so. Josep Riba invited Chambers to introduce himself and his background. Chambers stated that he had been born into the Cox family, which owned a private business enterprise with a turnover of billions of dollars. It had originated in the newspaper business and over time expanded into the automotive and multiple other industries. In 2022 he had sold out his shares in the family business, for a very large sum.

Riba then asked whether he had subsequently devoted himself to human rights and the rights of disadvantaged people, and secondly how long he had been devoted to the cause of Palestine. Chambers replied that yes, he might be described as a rights activist and a philanthropist, though he was not fond of the word. On Palestine specifically he had an interest since his teenage years, when he had been introduced to the subject by Jewish friends in Brooklyn. He had attended some non-violent demonstrations and had donated to organisations devoted to medical aid and prisoner welfare. But his philanthropic activities had absolutely not been limited to Palestine in particular.

Riba then asked how his finance for these causes had been organised. Chambers replied that until 2023 his donations had been decided and managed personally. But from 2023, after the sale of his company shares, his giving had been managed through a formal foundation, which went by the public name of the Babushki Collective. There were three trustees besides him, and the process of decision making was very collegiate. Riba asked whether any money had ever been donated to any organisation subject to US sanctions. Chambers replied no, and this was particularly checked in every case with the Office of Foreign Assets Control of the US Treasury. The foundation could not afford to be at odds with the US government on this, which could affect all of its work.

Riba then asked specifically about donations to Gaza, and whether these had increased. Chambers replied yes, they had. The focus of giving shifted to the pressing issue of the time – this had across time been race relations in the USA or environmentalism. Then the genocide in Gaza had changed the focus. They had concentrated on medical aid for children and the provision of food and potable water and transport out of dangerous areas. He said Gaza was “the prevailing moral issue of our time”. Riba then asked if he was at, and to what extent he took part in, the Palestine Action event at the Elbit factory.

Chambers said that he would dispute the description of Palestine Action as an organisation. It was more of an idea. The focus was to disrupt Elbit, the largest Israeli weapons producer. After the 2023 Israeli bombing of a Gaza hospital, in which 250 were killed including many children, there was a protest at the Elbit factory in New Hampshire. He had gone along as it was close to where he was living. Riba asked what he had done at the protests. Chambers replied he had been present at two protests. At the first he had chained himself to the door of the factory with a bicycle lock, blocking entry. Another group had been blocking the road to the factory. At the second he had been with a group of about 1,000 people blocking the road to the factory, and had given media interviews. Riba asked whether, at this time in October and November 2023, there had been any allegation that Palestine Action was a terrorist organisation? Chambers replied there was none. It had much later been controversially branded a terrorist organisation in the UK, in mid-2025.


Fergie Chambers gives his evidence in court. I am visible as the shock of white hair on the left of the public gallery. Note the half empty gallery though dozens were refused entry.

Riba said that a tweet referred to in the extradition request referenced a further Palestine Action protest. Had he taken part in that protest? Chambers replied that he had not. At this stage a judge interrupted. It was not interpreted, but I am told that he reminded Riba that this hearing was not for the substance of the case. Chambers then answered on the relevant point of the question of “fires”.

Chambers said he had absolutely not caused a fire. Nobody had caused any fire. To the best of his knowledge, there had never been a fire at any Palestine Action protest in the United States. (At this point I suggested to the activist next to me that it was however a good idea. She kicked me in the shins. Police and security forces of the world, please note that this was a joke to relieve the tension.)

Riba asked about the allegation Chambers had paid bail for the offenders at the protest. Chambers replied this was true. Providing bail for protestors who could not afford it was a regular activity of his Foundation, because often protestors could not afford bail and the threat of imprisonment could chill citizens’ rights. Bail had been provided for George Floyd protestors and many others.

Riba then asked why he had left the USA. Chambers replied his family had decided, on political grounds, they no longer wished to be part of the USA which was complicit in Genocide. There was increasing political repression in the USA. They had gone to Tunisia because he had friends there and was fluent in French. He had family nearby. He also wished to study Islam with non-fundamentalist scholars.

Riba said that the extradition request characterised him as leaving the USA on the run. Was he aware of any charges against him in the USA? Chambers replied there were no legal issues prior to his departure. He had left on his own passport and used his own credit cards in his own name. In Tunisia he had lived next door to the US Ambassador. He had developed a public profile in Tunisia through his football club. He had never been in hiding.

Riba said that 80% of the money he had transferred to Tunisia had gone into the football club and into investment in gyms. Why was this? Chambers replied that he had made a sponsorship deal with Club Africain which had grown and grown until he was deeply involved in the club. He had provided over US $4 million to the team, which had with its fans a culture of support for Palestine. He was very much interested in sport, and with the gyms they had developed sportswear lines. His involvement with the club had started because he was contacted by a friend who was their former Club President. The football club was deeply in debt and he had been asked to help. They had paid off much of the debt, improved training facilities and coaching, and invested in the women’s team.

Riba then said the US extradition request stated that he had visited the Iranian Embassy. Chambers replied that this was untrue in essence. At a boat show he had spoken to the Iran stall of his desire to see Iran, and they had told him that, despite his US passport, he might still get a US visa. One day therefore he had stopped by the Iranian Embassy and gone in to ask about visa application. However the Embassy was closed and he only spoke to the local receptionist. That was the entire extent of his contact. He saw the extradition request stated two visits; that was simply untrue.

Riba said the extradition request stated that immediately after entering the Iranian Embassy he had made a US $20,000 donation to an organisation called the Alliance for Global Justice, was this true? Chambers replied he could not recall the precise timing, but he had made the donation to the Alliance for Global Justice, which was a perfectly legal registered non-profit organisation based in Arizona. That concluded Chambers’s questioning.

There was a further defence witness, a forensic accounting expert, who gave evidence that he had investigated all of the international transfers in question and subsequent use of funds, and could find no evidence of any illegal or suspicious transactions. After this questioning, the prosecution responded. Juan Hernández Villalba was not giving an inch. He fully supported the US extradition request, stressing the terrorism angle and stating that the request properly corresponded to the Spanish offences of public disorder and financing of terrorism. He said that such dangerous conduct should not be minimised. He denied the challenges to the technical content of the request and stated that the Attorney General of New Hampshire could be accounted a “judicial authority” for the purposes of the Treaty. Hernández Villalba spoke at length, reading very quickly in a monotone. The judges took extensive notes.

This was followed by Aitor Martínez concluding for the defence. You may recall that Aitor represented me in the case against UC Global and David Morales Guillen over spying on Julian Assange (and incidentally on me) in the Ecuador Embassy – a trial stopped by the alleged death of David Morales. Strangely enough, here we were back in the same courtroom where I had given my evidence. Aitor made a powerful and intellectually muscular presentation, demolishing the extradition request in ten points, on the grounds outlined above. Below is a video of Aitor’s speech. There is one point that Aitor makes which exactly mirrors what is happening in the UK and it is extremely significant. At 14 minutes and 47 seconds into the video, Aitor makes a point he calls “extremely serious” – that the extradition request details the serious felonies the New Hampshire Elbit protestors were charged with, including riot and criminal damage. But the extradition request fails to note that they were acquitted of all felonies and only convicted of a misdemeanour of public disorder, attracting a six-month jail sentence – which falls below the limit for extradition.

The US and Spanish authorities are using precisely the same trick as the UK authorities in overcharging Palestine Action activists with serious offences in order to portray them as terrorists, then treating those charges as facts of what happened, even though they result in no convictions. In both the English and Scottish judicial review proceedings this has been done systematically, citing charges particularly of violent disorder and aggravated burglary even though there has been not a single conviction and double-digit acquittals. Sir James Eadie KC did this particularly egregiously in the Supreme Court in London last week, referring to carrying of weapons and violent disorder repeatedly, never mentioning the not guilty verdicts. It is fascinating the exact same tactic is employed across Europe and over the Atlantic. One might posit some form of collaboration.

What the video does not show is the reaction of the judges. At first they looked highly engaged. After about 15 minutes they seemed to be signalling they were affronted, drawing back from Aitor in their seats while increasing their height. Towards the end, the judge in the centre looked engaged again, the judge to his right appeared to find the whole thing highly amusing, and the judge to his left had made up his mind and was ready for lunch, putting his papers carefully together and tapping them vertically on the desk to level them up, while Aitor still had five minutes to go. All of which was interesting, but did not really indicate which way they were thinking.


Finally, Fergie Chambers was invited to give a brief closing statement. Chambers said he could not understand why he had been in prison for four months, for what amounted at most to speaking emotionally and creating a minor public disturbance. He had never had a history of violence, never advocated violence, or associated with any terrorist organisation. He was torn from his family, who needed him. He had missed his grandmother’s funeral a week ago. He had a five year old son, and his wife was pregnant. All he was asking for from the court was Justice, Reason and Mercy. On that emotional note, the court ended, and we left the white court into the white corridor, before heading up in the lift and out of the armoured greenhouse, blinking away our snow blindness and trying to make sense of what we had just seen. A decision is expected in approximately one week.

A Bearable Version?

“Man who transported Omagh bomb was an MI5 and Garda agent, inquiry told.” People on Twitter are wondering why this is not one of the biggest stories in the world. But I expect that everyone would just have assumed that this was the case. I mean, of course he was. What else would he have been? Similarly, Kit Klarenberg writes:

Britain’s MI5 faces scrutiny for deceiving the public and the courts about its connections to the Manchester Arena bomber and its protection of a violent neo-Nazi informant. Leaked emails show the intel agency secretly working to gut legislation that would bar British officials and spies from lying when addressing state investigations.

On October 21, Britain’s Public Office (Accountability) Bill, known as the Hillsborough Law, completed its committee stage in the House of Lords. The legislation, which would establish a “duty of candour” making it a criminal offense for government agents to lie to or conceal information from inquiries and investigations, is now due for a vote by the Lords. Members of Parliament’s upper chamber can delay the legislation for a year, potentially killing it altogether, or attempt to force amendments to its terms.

Emails unearthed by The Grayzone show that for years, Britain’s domestic spy agency, MI5, has covertly managed a campaign against Hillborough in parliament. In the House of Lords, former MI5 directors have kept a “list” of “allies” who could be relied on to weaken the bill or kill it altogether. McCallum personally tried to negotiate what he called “a bearable version of the Hillsborough Law” with Prime Minister Andy Burnham before he took office.

The proposed law is named for an April 1989 crowd stampede that killed 97 Liverpool fans at Hillsborough stadium in Sheffield. A public inquiry and separate inquest much later found local police falsified and suppressed evidence to wrongly blame Liverpool football club supporters for the mass carnage, which was actually instigated by police, while peddling repulsive, libelous allegations against innocent fans. The Hillsborough Law would impose criminal penalties of 2 to 14 years in prison for government workers who lie to public investigators.

In the Labour party’s 2024 manifesto, Keir Starmer pledged to implement the bill. But Labour has since dragged its feet after coming under pressure from members of Parliament who worried that MI5, MI6 and GCHQ would be insulated from scrutiny. The Commons finally passed the legislation in July. With the Lords vote looming, campaigners fear the intelligence services will find a way to insulate themselves from the obligation to tell the truth, as the legislation mandates.

Leaked MI5 emails show these concerns are well-founded. While victims’ families have fought for decades to implement legislation forcing state officials to tell the truth, the leaks reveal that senior agency officials responded to their campaign by conspiring to subvert efforts to demand accountability for police and intelligence agencies. Again and again, the emails showcase the agency’s pathological habit of lying to conceal grave crimes.

One exchange reveals Director General Ken McCallum and his predecessor, now Baroness Eliza Manningham-Buller, lobbied ministers and peers to either create a special “exemption” for MI5 in the Hillsborough Law, or kill the legislation outright. McCallum privately admitted that it was difficult to oppose the proposed law publicly because “it looks like one is against telling the truth.” This did little to deter the agency from seeking to wreck the bill, however.

MI5 has consistently opposed the duty of candor on flimsy “national security” grounds. The emails show the agency believed it had convinced ministers of the need to “carve us out” of the law, until victims’ families forced the government to apply the duty to MI5 in the bill’s final form.

A ‘hard bill to oppose politically’ because it ‘looks like one is against telling the truth’

Since then, senior MI5 officials have overseen clandestine efforts to ensure Britain’s upper Parliament either secures a duty of candor exemption for Britain’s spying agencies, or votes the law down.

For years, McCallum used a private, pseudonymous email address to keep Manningham-Buller informed about his covert lobbying of British Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s incoming administration on the legislation. Official guidelines strongly discourage British government officials from using private accounts to conduct state affairs, a fact which raises serious questions about the pair’s commitment to transparency standards.

In the message, McCallum acknowledged having secretly sought “to negotiate a bearable version of the Hillsborough Law” directly with Burnham before the premier had even taken office. The MI5 chief stated that Burnham’s team “hasn’t yet found its feet on our domain,” suggesting he believed the incoming government was composed of relative lightweights into whom he could easily sink his claws.


The oddly tender message was the latest in a months-long exchange which saw the current and former MI5 bosses obsess over how to subvert the Hillsborough Law. In an explosive email two months prior, the current spy chief openly admitted the Hillsborough Law was “a [very] hard bill to oppose politically” because it “looks like one is against telling the truth” and “wants to deny bereaved families some (perceived) meaning from the deaths of their loved ones.” The pair were determined to try, however.

McCallum went on to reveal the exact talking points he and his subordinates were deploying in order to prevent government agents from being compelled to tell the truth: MI5 had been working “consistently to say, carefully but firmly,” that while “we applaud the intent of this bill,” it risks causing “serious damage to [national security].” The justifications listed included claims that the bill would tie up intelligence officers in court and cause MI5’s “international partners” to think twice about cooperating, given that the law “could force, under pain of criminal sanction, the release of their material.”


“Legislation of this sort will keep legal firms happy, but gum up delivery for the average citizen/taxpayer,” he complained. “Is this really what we need?”

McCallum insisted that “the [candour] model the government has proposed gives the campaigners 90% of what they want,” but he complained that victims’ families “keep ratcheting, in ways that now risk wildly disproportionate effect [sic] on national security.” The MI5 Director General was particularly worried about the Hillsborough Law being debated and voted upon by parliament while the agency was embroiled in several ongoing scandals, arising from the longstanding propensity of MI5 officials – including Manningham-Buller – to shamelessly lie.

‘Manchester Arena, STEAK KNIFE, etc.’

McCallum specifically referenced the deadly 2017 Manchester Arena bombing as a potentially problematic line of inquiry for the spy agency.

Demand for the Hillsborough Law intensified significantly after an official investigation found MI5 missed major opportunities to avoid the worst terrorist attack in British history. In May 2017, an Islamic extremist named Salman Abedi blew himself and 22 young people up during an Ariana Grande concert at Manchester Arena. Britain’s intelligence services had enjoyed a covert relationship with Abedi and his family, who fought to topple the government of Libyan President Moammar Ghadafi with London’s assistance.

McCallum publicly professed to be “profoundly sorry” his agency failed to avert the attack, but neglected to mention an anonymous MI5 witness lied to the inquiry about intelligence held on Abedi before the attack.

The MI5 also faced a major public relations crisis from its handling of a serial killer and pedophile it cultivated as a secret agent within the Irish Republican Army (IRA). The intelligence agency launched an internal probe into the agent, known as “Stakeknife,” after it was caught lying to official investigators about him. Having initially claimed it had no ties with the agent at all, MI5 turned over hundreds of documents exposing its intimate relationship with Stakeknife after investigators declined to press charges against agency officials.

In findings published in December 2025, the internal probe, known as Operation Kenova, openly criticized MI5 for concealing the extraordinary extent of its relationship with the agent. On top of withholding crucial information, investigators scolded Manningham-Buller for publicly alleging MI5 had no knowledge of or involvement in London’s “disgraceful” relationship with the notorious predator.

Censored passages in the Kenova report revealed Manningham-Buller consciously concealed important details about MI5’s dark alliance with Stakeknife. As this outlet revealed, references in an April 2025 Daily Telegraph article to Stakeknife being managed by “intelligence service operatives” were secretly removed on MI5’s orders.

“We didn’t get approached in advance on this – very poor form,” an MI5 official complained in an email to Manningham-Buller at the time.

The Telegraph piece was also censored to remove passages stating MI5 had been “found to have lied” about its management of a violence-“obsessed” misogynist who infiltrated Neo-Nazi circles known as “Agent-X.” The BBC revealed that MI5 protected ‘Agent-X’ from prosecution for horrendous crimes against his former partner, then assisted his escape from Britain, which enabled him to assault more women overseas with local intelligence agency protection.

A damning Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office report this July revealed senior MI5 officials provided the real name of ‘Agent X’ to the BBC, then systematically denied having done so to multiple different courts as the agency struggled in vain to prevent transmission of the BBC’s discoveries and protect his identity. MI5 was eventually “found to have lied” to an extraordinary degree in clear violation of British law.

Manningham-Buller warned the MI5 Director General in May 2026 that she intended to “raise concerns re duty of candour,” referring to the Hillsborough Law requiring agents to tell the truth. She was concerned at the time about a forthcoming Lords debate on the King’s speech, the Manchester Arena bomber’s British intelligence ties and MI5’s handling of the serial-killing secret agent known as Stakeknife.

“If helpful to refresh on any of that, let me know,” the MI5 Director General assured her. During the debate, Manningham-Buller did not raise the duty of candor issue, focusing instead on the supposed threat of Russian “influence operations.”

Regarding the Hillsborough Law, McCallum wrote that “At minimum,” it was “worth pausing to reflect properly on the detail,” noting that such bureaucratic hand-wringing was “classic [House of Lords] territory.”

Mired in scandal over past lies, MI5 prepares to infiltrate parliament

For almost two years, Baroness Manningham-Buller had been constructing a clandestine coalition of Lords who could be expected to oppose the Hillsborough Law in part or whole. She was joined by fellow former MI5 Director Generals Andrew Parker and Jonathan Evans, who are both Lords. In January 2022, Manningham-Buller became chair of the British upper chamber’s influential Conduct Committee, which scrutinizes ethical standards, and can sanction them for misbehavior. In the days that followed, Manningham-Buller privately revealed to McCallum she accepted the position after heavy lobbying by Jonathan Evans.


Nearly three years later, she emailed MI5 headquarters asking for clarity on whether “the ‘duty of candour’ problem had been addressed.” An MI5 official named David R. cautioned the issue remained “very tricky,” but sounded an optimistic note.

The agency was “in a good place with ministers on the need to carve us out of it,” he wrote, explaining that MI5 was in the process of establishing a “code of ethics” which would demonstrate that the British security state was already policing itself and needed no outside interference. When completed, the code “can be published as a demonstration of how we are already fully candid in inquiries etc, and therefore we don’t need the duty of candour to apply to us,” David declared. Still, the agency feared “this will be very bumpy in parliament,” with government ministers “concerned by the optics and politics of it.”


Within MI5, these worries were heightened by impending “difficult media [reports] around our alleged lack of candour in relation to various issues.” Chief among those “various issues” was Operation Kenova, the MI5 official explained. 

“This will be an unhelpful backdrop,” David lamented. “Ken thinks this will be difficult for us and he’ll be doing a fair bit of parliamentary engagement on it in due course, and we hope you and Jonathan will help too.” 

The MI5 apparatchik sought to arrange a meeting with Manningham-Buller at HQ on the Hillsborough Law. He also introduced her to an MI5 official named Kate, the agency’s “lead on all-things-legislation” and “duty of candour” specifically. 

Kate wished to regularly update Baroness Manningham-Buller and Jonathan Evans on MI5’s “interests in parliament,” which included forthcoming legislation on employment rights and the military. David mentioned Lord Harold Carter had recently visited MI5 headquarters to make introductions, and had offered “to be another supportive voice in the Lords on our stuff.” 

Manningham-Buller responded that she, Evans and Parker would “do what we can.” The former MI5 Director General was eager to know who else was on the agency’s “list” of “allies” in parliament.

MI5 secretly recruits Lords to “oppose the whole bill”

MI5’s ally list was short. David named Lords David Anderson, the former terrorism legislation reviewer, and Alex Carlile, a national security hawk, as occasional contacts, with the Lords Justice and Home Affairs Committee and Lord Tim Clement-Jones seen as friendly. MI5 wanted Dido Harding, the COVID-era health security chief, as an advocate because she was strong on data and tech.

Manningham-Buller vetoed her — she had “a very low opinion of Dido” — and proposed targeting former members of parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee and ex-cabinet secretaries instead. Peter Ricketts was reliably supportive; so was Mark Sedwill, when he “bothered to turn up.”



By January, with the bill advancing, MI5’s legislation lead, Kate, was sending Evans, Manningham-Buller and Parker regular updates. HLN campaigners had unexpectedly objected to the bill’s “national security model,” which MI5 had thought workable, and the government was preparing to change the bill without notifying the agency.

“We have significant concerns about the pace at which the [national security] community is being required to advise on the potential risks of amendments and about the long term consequences of some of the options,” Kate cautioned. However, with Lords debates imminent, MI5 was “preparing to engage” with lawmakers to scupper the bill.


Within days, Manningham-Buller had privately spoken to shadow justice minister Lord Richard Keen and shadow cabinet office minister Lady Simone Finn. The pair planned to lead Lords opposition to the legislation, with Keen telling Manningham-Buller they were “inclined to oppose the whole bill.” Meanwhile, “Blairite ministers” Lords George Robertson and David Blunkett were seen as likely allies, too. Evans approvingly chimed in that Finn was “hostile to [the] whole bill.” He pondered, “what is the best way to get her a brief on any [national security] concerns?”

An MI5 operative known only as “Gareth M.” was enthusiastic about Manningham-Buller’s covert outreach to Lady Finn, approvingly quoting the parliamentarian’s recent scathing dismissal of the Hillsborough Law as a major, unwanted threat to state secrecy. Gareth was “confident we will be able to provide Lady Finn (and Lord Keen) with our objective view of national security matters/concerns as policy depts. develop their thinking.” Lord Carlile had recently visited agency headquarters, with McCallum concurrently speaking “to a range of other MPs.”

In late March, Manningham-Buller told Gareth she’d learned a recent meeting with Hillsborough families had featured “lots of strong words” over the delay in the legislation’s implementation. Gareth revealed McCallum had “various further meetings” with ministers and then-premier Keir Starmer. While the duty of candor would apply “at an individual level” to MI5 officers, spy service chiefs enjoyed an “element of control” over how their agencies interacted with official investigations. Coverups may still be state sanctioned, in other words.


Though the MI5’s campaign to defang the transparency bill has largely escaped media scrutiny, but some in the political sphere have taken notice. In the debate on the legislation in the House of Lords in May, civil liberties campaigner Baroness Shami Chakrabarti, apparently wise to the agency’s lobbying campaign, warned that “a blanket exemption for the security agencies would be no kind of Hillsborough Law at all.”

If the leaked emails are any guide, that may be the entire point.

The Very Condition of Human Grandeur


Today, the promises of transhumanism and posthumanism are multiplying. These are ideological currents according to which, sooner or later, technology will eliminate all disease and pain, as well as aging and even death itself.

Precisely because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality, while entire peoples suffer from poverty and oppression.

In the face of this mirage, which promotes the illusion of human beings perfected by cybernetics and biotechnology, Christian anthropology reminds us that a limitation is not a manufacturing defect, but rather the very condition of human grandeur.

This or Peter Thiel, JD Vance. You cannot have both.