Thursday, 19 November 2026

A Pernicious Pardon

Henry Hill writes:

Today’s piece has been something of a journey. First it was going to be about the Government’s plans to abolish the City of London Police, one of this country’s most effective forces, as part of a grandiose plan to merge everything into national super-forces. It’s a terrible idea, and obviously in tension (as with so much else) with Any Burnham’s putative devolution agenda.

We’ll return to that, because I got distracted. First, by the increasingly incredulous messages of contacts who have been diving into the Milburn Review. I touched on this on Monday, but the detail really is extraordinary, in that there is no detail at all. Nothing! Every number in the report, more or less, seems to have been plucked from the aether, or from unpublished “internal data”.

But we’ll return to that, too. Because in the end, I think it would be wrong not to mark the fact that this government has just pardoned Sarah Catt and expunged her criminal record. If you’re unfamiliar with Catt, please consult this news story, which despite dating back only to the Coalition reads like an artefact of an entirely different age, which in moral terms perhaps it was. In summary, she is one of very few women in Britain ever to be convicted and jailed for an illegal abortion. 

You might imagine the threshold for that to be quite high, and it was. In the sterilised language generally employed to hide the character of such things, Catt terminated her 39-week pregnancy in order to hide the fact that she was having an affair, as she assumed the man with whom she was cheating was the father. But 39 weeks is full-term. She killed a fully developed, perfectly healthy baby which needed only to be born.

It’s difficult to know what to write about this, really. How to approach it? There is a good procedural angle, which is normally my forte. Say what you like about the assisted suicide crowd, but at least they tabled an actual Bill, even if they then tried to short-circuit every process related to it. The decriminalisation of abortion up to birth, a legal and social change every bit as seismic, was delivered via an amendment to what was then the Policing and Crime Bill, after less than an hour’s debate in the Commons. Or we might consider the American brainrot which animated the Labour MPs and narrow sect of activists who pushed through the reform; their pretence that this country’s abortion settlement (amongst the most generous in Europe) was under threat, that Roe vs Wade in the States had any significance here at all.

Alternatively, the mind-numbingly moronic character of much of the coverage of what little debate there was. Of particular note was the emphasis on women being prosecuted under legislation “from the Victorian times”, as if it was an unpardonable assault to the dignity of women to subject them to last season’s statute. Obviously, as anyone familiar with our constitution would know, that legislation (the Offences Against the Person Act 1861) was subsequently modified by both the Infant Life (Preservation) Act 1929 and the more famous Abortion Act 1967, and it was under that framework that any prosecution took place. It is a virtue of our system that good law does not have an expiry date and can simply be modified as needed by future parliaments. We do not need regularly to re-pass legislation making poisoning people illegal.

Perhaps again we might consider the grotesque and absurd contradictions which our modern habit of passing whatever law or policy makes people feel nice in the moment as produced. For example, it is now legal – sorry, not criminal – to kill a baby in the womb at the same age where if it were lost to a miscarriage, the parents could get a special certificate officially recognising that it was a person. Or that under Labour’s new employment law you will soon be able to terminate your full-term baby and then take time off work because it died. Were we feeling really spicy, we might even dive into some of the second-order logical consequences which follow the new regime. Abortion was never, historically, supposed to be merely an option on a menu; the argument was always that it should be rare and regrettable, but criminalising it (below a certain threshold) did more harm than good.

But if keeping a baby is merely a choice, a choice lacking any moral weight and which a woman can make at any point; if there is not even the possibility of a woman discovering she’s pregnant when it’s too late to do anything about it, well… what exactly is the logic of forcing the man to pay child support? The original case was that men should not be allowed to run away from an obligation which the woman could not run away from. That doesn’t hold if it isn’t an obligation at all, and can be escaped at-will at any point. In the end, however, I think all that might just distract from the sheer moral monstrousness of abortion up to birth. We have decriminalised the killing of babies which, if delivered, could live — not even live with handicaps, such as premature babies sometimes endure, but live fully and healthily. It is now, de facto, legal to kill such babies for any reason their parents, or at least one of their parents, may find convenient.

Nor will it be easy, if this logic is conceded to draw a hard line at “birth”. Apart from the umbilical cord, which a full-term and many premature babies can live without if delivered, no magical transformation occurs when a child exits its mother. The critical difference between a one-day-old and a minus-one-day-old is that you can see one, and you can’t see the other, and what you can’t see you can convince yourself isn’t entirely real. This approach is, not to mince words, deeply, deeply stupid. How else to describe an attempt to establish our definition of personhood using the rules of Peek-a-Boo? To anyone who grasps the concept of object permanence, on the other hand, it is very difficult to create a meaningful moral distinction between Sarah Catt and a woman who smothers her newborn. And there are indeed people who suggest that we should not prosecute women who do that. How old does a child have to be before its mother loses this strange, inverted Roman right to kill it without consequence? I’m not sure. Ask Lindsay Clancy’s jury.

Defenders of these changes tend to argue that nobody tries to procure a late-term abortion for the jollies, that they must have good reasons, that it causes them grief and suffering and that is surely enough. This defence fails, and fails abjectly, for two reasons. First, in terms of whether or not something should be criminal conduct, it simply doesn’t matter at all. Even if all the above applies to a given case, that is known as “mitigating circumstances” and it is a consideration during sentencing, not conviction. Indeed, one of the bizarre things about this reform is that such logic was already giving campaigners what they wanted; women jailed for illegal abortions using pills-by-post were already having their sentences overturned on appeal. Second, because it does not apply to every case. Bad actors exist. If your position is that nobody should ever be convicted and jailed for an abortion, you need to defend the very worst abortions done for the very worst reasons. Sarah Catt killed her baby to cover up an affair. If you don’t think society should act on that, your soul is sick.

Will anyone do anything about it? Who knows. There was no popular outcry for abortion up to birth, which has been the cause of cranks for decades. Neil O’Brien, the MP overseeing the Conservatives’ policy review, has tweeted about Catt’s pardon in a way which implies, at least, that he disapproves of it. Legally, a future government would need merely to repeal the relevant sections of the Policing and Crime Act and the pandemic-era legislation allowing for pills by post, which broke the in-person gatekeeping of access to abortifacients and allowed women to procure them for illegal abortions simply by lying about how far along they were.

Were a government prepared to do that, it would also be a welcome opportunity to send a clear signal to the courts that we do actually want the criminal sanctions attached to abortion law enforced, including prison sentences. An Act of Attainder restoring Catt’s conviction would be a start. As this government has demonstrated time and again, it is perfectly possible for a majority in Parliament to enact sweeping change very quickly indeed. But this change would involve being shouted at by activists and denounced by The Times. The last Tory government could not withstand that sort of pressure. The next, if we even get another, may not either.

No comments:

Post a Comment