Talk about different times. On 2 November 2003, The Observer published an article by Miranda Sawyer calling for the age of consent to be lowered to 12; the following year, Sawyer made the same case in an hour-long documentary on Channel 4. On 9 November 2003, The Observer kindly published my letter arguing instead, as I argue again now after 23 years to the month, that it ought to be a criminal offence to engage in any sort of sexual activity with any person under the age of 18 who was more than two years younger than oneself, with a maximum sentence equal to twice the difference in age, and with the abolition of different rules for “positions of trust”.
We need to ban abortion and contraception for those under 18 at least without parental knowledge and consent, just as they thankfully cannot now be given puberty blockers. What sort of parent would want to put his underage daughter on the Pill? There is only one possible reason for doing so. The Thatcher Government secured a judicial fiat that, without bothering to ask Parliament, abolished the age of consent altogether. Gillick competence ought instead to be called Thatcher competence. The Major Government did write Thatcher competence into the Age of Legal Capacity (Scotland) Act 1991. But it is applied in Northern Ireland on no apparent authority. Even in England and Wales, it has never been subject to a parliamentary vote. Let there be one now.
We need to rule out the legal possibility of being a specifically sexual assailant below an age of consent that had been raised to 18, thereby correcting the anomaly that had existed since 2003. In that year, a male heterosexual age of consent of 16 was created by default due to political horse-trading among the feminist and gay groups around Harriet Harman, of all people, which insisted that both sexes and all acts be treated in exactly the same way. Yet the age of criminal responsibility remains 10, meaning that boys can be prosecuted for rape, itself significantly redefined in 2003, six years before they can legally have consensual sex. And they are. Indeed, boys who allege abuse by women are routinely accused of rape.
We need the replacement of the existing categories of sexual assault with aggravating circumstances to the general categories of offences against the person, such that the sentences could be doubled. There should be no anonymity either for adult defendants or for adult complainants. Either we have an open system of justice, or we do not. We need to specify that intoxication was a bar to sexual consent only insofar as it would have been a bar to driving. We need to end the blocking of progress into paid or voluntary work even though one had been acquitted. C5 notices should be outlawed. And we need to make it a criminal offence for anyone aged 21 or over to buy or sell sex, with equal sentencing on both sides. The Universal Basic Income, the Jobs Guarantee, and the dividends from public stakes in the FTSE 500 companies, distributed equally to everyone, would remove any conceivable excuse for prostituting oneself. That would include filmed or photographed prostitution, by banning certain categories of which we have demonstrated that the technology existed for a total ban.
There cannot be a “free” market in general, yet not in drugs, or prostitution, or pornography, or unrestricted alcohol, or unrestricted gambling. That is an important part of why there must not be a “free” market in general, which is a political choice, not a law of nature. Enacting and enforcing laws against drugs, prostitution and pornography, and regulating alcohol, tobacco and gambling, are clear examples of State intervention in, and regulation of, the economy. Radical change would be impossible if the workers, the youth and the poor were in a state of stupefaction. Contrived in the past, that baleful situation is being contrived again.
For example, to pay for the war, Ukraine is legalising the pornography that had been legally prohibited and practically unknown in the Soviet Union, but with which post-Soviet Russia was flooded to placate the young male population during the larceny of their country by means of the economic “shock therapy” that created today’s oligarchs, who were of course initially drawn from the nomenklatura, since where else might they have come from? “Sex work” has always been encouraged when the young men have needed to be stupefied, and it still is. The corporate capitalist pornogrification of our own society is no accident. In welcoming the endorsement of Bonnie Blue, Reform UK has picked its side, the same side as the Green Party on this as on the war.
So let no one accuse me of lining up with Lady Labour-Lanyard as she demanded, with the full power of the State, that digital ID be produced and her risk assessment carried out before anything more than holding hands would be permitted in the back row of the cinema. We know about her, anyway. We may be on the cusp of the formal disclosure that Britain was really run by state-employed or state-contracted middle-class women who thought that they were left-wing solely because they did not speak or dress like Hyacinth Bucket, and who had sex with each other and with teenage boys, often obtained commercially from the ever-larger desperate end of what was once the working class.
I have had my own dealings with such, I believe Russell Brand to be guilty of the offences of which he had been convicted, I await the prosecution of his unsuccessful accusers, and I note that if there was some problem with his barrister’s conduct of the case, then that did not prevent the jury from both convicting him unanimously and acquitting him unanimously. But he retains the absolute right to maintain his innocence, and his wife retains the absolute right to recount the contents of his conversations or correspondence with her. Even if he were not famous, then he could not now hope to be acquitted of anything due to another measure from 2003, the midpoint nadir of Tony Blair’s horrendous second term. In that year, the House of Commons approved the Iraq War. As the price of that war, it passed the hunting ban on the specific understanding that it would be a dead letter from the start, with neither the Prime Minister nor the Government Chief Whip voting in favour of it.
It abolished the protection against double jeopardy. It extended Police stop and search powers, and it allowed for persons who were merely “accompanying” the Police to participate actively in searches. It enabled the Police to issue conditional cautions that might still lead to a prosecution. It provided for leading City figures to be acquitted of fraud by judges sitting alone.
It abolished the right of prisoners to apply to the High Court for bail, but it extended the right of the prosecution to appeal against the decision of a Magistrates’ Court to grant bail. It required that a list of defence witnesses, along with their names and addresses, be given for interview by the Police, and that the details of any defence expert witness instructed be given to the prosecution, whether or not that witness were then used.
It empowered the prosecution to appeal against rulings of Crown Court judges that terminated cases or excluded evidence.
It introduced indeterminate sentence of “imprisonment for public protection” for offences that would otherwise carry a maximum sentence of 10 years.
It made it a criminal offence for two people under the age of 16 to kiss each other; like the hunting ban, that was on the stated understanding that only a message was being sent, with absolutely no intention of any attempt at enforcement. And even as it restricted the cross-examination of prosecution witnesses on their own criminal records, it permitted the admission of hearsay, and of a defendant’s previous convictions and general “bad character”.
Brand was unable to find any character witnesses, but it would presumably not have mattered if he had had dozens. I had a parade of past and present members of both Houses of Parliament, senior Catholic and Anglican clergy, distinguished academics, prominent journalists, and others, including several of my supposed victims. But I was not allowed to call any of them in March 2020, when possibly any one, probably any two, and certainly any three would have guaranteed enough jurors to have prevented a conviction even by majority verdict.
On 8 May 2025, I was declared “exonerated” by His Honour Judge Nathan Adams from the bench of Durham Crown Court. Exonerated of something very specific, but it makes all the difference. Though entirely unconnected to the charges, it had been admitted as “propensity” to secure my first conviction, despite there being absolutely no evidence at all to support the charges themselves and despite a previous trial's having collapsed a year earlier. Thanks to Blair’s abolition of the presumption of innocence, that conviction made and makes it effectively impossible for me ever to be acquitted of anything, even publishing blog posts that did not exist and which the only person claiming ever to have seen had first failed to present himself in court, and then been sacked from the Police because of his conduct of my case. I was still left with no option but to plead guilty in order to spare what little remained of my physical and mental health. But I didn’t do it. No one did it. As with the previous charges, it never happened.
No one, absolutely no one at all, has ever said to my face that they thought that I was guilty. I once again invite each and every Member of Parliament for the area covered by Durham County Council, each and every member of Durham County Council, each and every member of Lanchester Parish Council, each and every member of the Board of the Catholic Safeguarding Standards Agency, each and every member of the Hexham and Newcastle Diocesan Safeguarding Committee, each and every member of the Hexham and Newcastle Diocesan Safeguarding Team, and each and every bishop, priest or deacon of the Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle, to contact davidaslindsay@hotmail.com if they thought that I was factually or morally guilty of any criminal charge that had ever been brought against me. Not legally guilty. Factually and morally guilty, in that I had in fact committed any such offence. No name would be published except at the request of its bearer, but if anyone ever did get in touch, then the readers of this site would be the first to know. The current total is zero, as it has been since 28 July 2021.
I love the way certain London hacks think they've blacklisted you or something.
ReplyDeleteI'll never snort cocaine in their town again? I have never snorted cocaine in that or any other town, and I never shall. They cannot begin to get their heads around that.
Delete