Thursday, 19 November 2026

The Uncomfortable Truth About Rape Trials

Lord Chancellors used to be silks, of which the Labour Party has never had any shortage. But now we have to make do with Alex Norris. As when there was apparently a taboo against debating immigration, I must have been in a coma when there was an absence of discussion of the rape gangs. One such has been convicted today, with only Mohammed Hassan having an Islamic name, or indeed being nonwhite. Norman Macksoni’s surname is unusual, but it originates in these Islands. The other members are Philip Young, Richard Wilkins, Connor Sanderson-Doyle and Dean Hamilton, just as the assailants of Gisèle Pelicot were French by even the tightest definition.

Those of us who never liked Russell Brand are content with justice. It is those who fell at his feet and kissed them who want vengeance, because he has made fools of them, something to which they ought to be accustomed. Variously centrists and right-wing populists, Brand exemplifies the absence of any difference between the two. Any “rape myths” did not preclude his unanimous conviction by a predominantly male jury but in the most liberal metropolis on Earth, just as Alex Salmond had been acquitted by a predominantly female jury in the most liberal city in Scotland, with the Scots Law requirement of corroboration making a majority verdict perhaps not quite so objectionable as it would be in England, although any jury system would be better without it, just as any legal system would be better with corroboration. More broadly, Adam King writes:

Your teenage son, shall we imagine, was never part of the in-crowd. Not one of “the lads”. Spent too much time alone, in fact. But he grew, and grew handsome, and at a party to which he was lucky to be invited, a girl of slightly higher status took him upstairs. She asked with a smile if he’d done it before, and he lied. He finished in seconds. “What the fuck?” Irrecoverable. His embarrassment manifests as gracelessness.

She’d been with all the hottest guys, but your son, her friends told her, was “a loser”. Tears on Snap. “Something happened which I didn’t want…”. A three-year police investigation, and a two-year wait for trial. No university. No friends. Just depression — first for him, then for his little sister as your marriage faltered. And now, shortly before trial, in the first conference you’ve been allowed to attend, the barrister — an iron-fist-velvet-glove type woman for whom you have re-mortgaged the house — answers your questions about the Crown’s disclosure.

The complainant, it turns out, has made three other allegations of rape against other young men, which were all dropped by the police. Ah yes, it is explained to your surprise, but the allegations might still all be true: the Court of Appeal has ruled that in those circumstances such reports must be kept from the jury.

Also disclosed is solid evidence that, in the weeks before and after the party, the complainant had consensual sex, in similar circumstances, with a number of others. Doesn’t that at least make it slightly more likely that the complainant consented with my son, you ask? No, no, the KC explains: s.41 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 says that evidence about previous sexual behaviour is inadmissible on the issue of consent, unless it’s more strikingly similar than it is here. After all, saying yes in the past hardly means she said yes on the night in question.

Of course not, you reply, but shouldn’t the jury at least be allowed to consider it? After all, if she had never had sex before, the Crown would be permitted to tell the jury that, wouldn’t they? Yes, she says, but there’s no way round it: a while back, the defence could put this kind of evidence in if the judge thought a trial would otherwise be unfair, but the discretion was removed in 2000. The new rules were heavily criticised in the first few years, including by judges, but, she informs you, we’ve all got used to it now.

Not disclosed, you note, is anything beyond a tiny sliver of the complainant’s social media messages. Surely the police should look at it all — you remember the case of Liam Allan, in which the defendant was saved from a wrongful conviction by text messages disclosed at the last-minute. Well, we did ask, says the barrister, but the police called it “speculation”, and the judge agreed: the disclosure rules have actually become more restrictive since the Allan case. You’ve read a lot about how rape has been “effectively decriminalised”, and that the odds are “stacked against” victims. You begin to wonder how accurate that line really is.

At trial, though, you look forward to hearing what your superstar silk says about the crotchless underwear the complainant was wearing. It’s not proof of consent of course — nothing like — but you can’t help but feel it’s something the jury ought to know about, to weigh in the balance. I mean, it’s not nothing, is it? But when the time comes, it isn’t mentioned. The barrister tells you that, in the end, she didn’t feel it would really land, and mutters something about a “troubling” case in Ireland. 

A senior Irish barrister in 2018, you discover, was subjected to an online hate campaign and threats of violence, for making exactly this sort of point in a rape trial. The defendant was acquitted, mind, and no disciplinary action was ever brought against her. And very recently, of course, there was the Russell Brand case, following which his KC was subjected to similar vilification in the media. And so you wonder quietly, glancing at the journalists who await the jury’s verdict in your son’s case, did this lady pull her punches, for the sake of her own reputation?

The minutes between a guilty verdict and a reconsideration of bail are supremely stressful for the defence team, especially in a high-profile trial like Brand’s. If a journalist hostile to your client’s case — especially one who, on behalf of your client, you have argued has perverted the course of justice — approaches you at that moment, sharp words should be avoided. And it was from this error that the pile-on against Ian Winter KC began.

The worst of it had to do with so-called “rape myths”. This is the idea that there exist powerful and dangerous stereotypes about rape, its victims and its perpetrators, that are all too easily believed, and which jurors are wont to fall for. Examples include the idea that it can’t be rape if the woman didn’t fight back; that a true complaint will be reported to the police immediately; or that women who wear revealing clothing must be open to sex.

In Brand’s trial, it seems that the suggestion was made on his behalf that the fact that a complainant did not physically resist, or leave, or complain to the police for many years, was somehow a point in the defence’s favour. Well, Bayes’ theorem — the inarguable logical rule by which evidence affects the probability of a hypothesis — is on the defence’s side here.

If evidence of a complainant having tried to escape makes guilt more likely — which it obviously does, and considerably so — then, all other things being equal, evidence that there was no such attempt makes guilt at least slightly less likely. The same goes for a “delayed” complaint: if an immediate call to police moves the scales of justice in the Crown’s favour (which it does), then a non-immediate call must do the same in the other direction (albeit, again, only to a limited extent, and all else being equal).

Now, like any plank of evidence that only weakly supports your case, if you make an inaccurate claim about its strength and lean on it too heavily, it is apt to snap. Juries are not stupid. So even if Winter had put one of these points too stridently — and it’s not entirely clear that he did; certainly the most widely impugned line “not one of them resisted or screamed or even tried to leave” simply points to a piece of the evidence — we have to ask: to whose benefit does a bad-defence point operate?

Since the turn of the century, an almost supernatural belief has developed, according to which the incantation of a rape myth — that without injuries it cannot have been rape, say — will inevitably be believed, despite its obvious falsity, and despite both the prosecutor and the judge explaining to the jury why it’s not true. How has this come about? Well, in an unavoidably imperfect system, with the criminal standard of proof being what it is (“so that the jury are sure”), guilty men will sometimes be acquitted. And that fact, given the unique horror of the crime of rape, provokes an urgent desire for a remedy, for an explanation we might be able to control. Unfortunately, as with some other magical beliefs, its adherents react poorly to heresy.

A decade ago, Professor Cheryl Thomas KC, of the UCL Jury Project, was commissioned by the senior judiciary to carry out a large-scale jury study, which was published in 2020. It was the first study to question real jurors (almost 800 of them) about rape myths — and it found, essentially, that the idea was itself a myth: juries do not believe such claims. Her work, it seems, was not widely publicised. Certainly, not a single one of those now lambasting Winter — from the Met Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley to the Justice Secretary Alex Norris — has engaged with it. But even if Professor Thomas is wrong, I have seen no attempt to explain why current judicial directions on the topic, set out at length in the judges’ handbook, are insufficient. (Example extract: “You must not assume that the way the complainant was dressed meant she was looking to have sex or willing to have sex if the opportunity came up. Just because someone dresses in revealing clothing it does not mean that they are inviting or willing to have sex.”)

Instead, sections of the press, politicians, and a couple of lawyers who should know better, have whipped up a febrile mob in an attempt to publicly shame Winter. Ian Hislop and others even mocked him for having acted for Harold Shipman 25 years ago (is this some kind of pattern?!), scorning his attempt to stay proceedings in Brand’s case for Abuse of Process due to the actions of the media. “Perverting the Course of Justice? Contempt?” they sneered. “Proceedings hadn’t even started when the documentary was made!” No, but that’s no bar to Perverting, or even common-law Contempt, actually.

Unsuccessful though the Abuse application was, the defence team would probably have been negligent if they hadn’t made one, given the unusual circumstances by which the allegations came to court: interviews with anonymous complainants, broadcast to millions, prompting the indicted complaints only then to come forward. Such applications, even if they fail to stop a trial, allow relevant facts to be aired and argued, and often elicit concessions of one sort or another in order to protect a defendant from unfairness.

And the Criminal Bar Association — led until September by Brand’s prosecutor, with the current Chair as deputy — rather than defending their member to any extent at all, appeared to jump on the bandwagon, uniquely issuing two statements praising the judge, and implicitly criticising Winter’s conduct. This can be contrasted with their — also unique — statement complaining of the “chilling effect” of the Contempt proceedings brought against Rajiv Menon KC for his actions in a recent Palestine Action trial during which, it is alleged, he breached the terms of a judicial order by informing the jury of the principle of “jury equity” (essentially their right to acquit according to conscience rather than the evidence). The matter is yet to be determined, and it is said Menon is at risk of a custodial sentence.

Barristers are not a protected class, immune from public criticism. No one has to like us. But what we are witnessing here is a campaign of intimidation tending to prevent defence lawyers from properly doing their job, and that is bad for justice, bad for victims, bad for the public. Inevitably, there are now calls in Parliament to create a specific disciplinary offence to stop barristers from relying on “rape myths”. However that might be drafted, the effect will be to restrict defendants — further than is already the case — from putting relevant and probative evidence before a jury.

“Fear no one!” goes the lawyers’ rallying cry. Quite right. But that doesn’t just mean standing up to grumpy judges. It means that we speak up for the rights of defendants in unpopular types of cases, and conduct those cases to the best of our ability and without regard to how our submissions might play out on TikTok to a politically hostile audience.

And let’s again be clear: rape has not been “effectively decriminalised”. Jurors convict of rape more often than they acquit, and more often than of GBH. We should not be putting our thumb on the scales of justice by preventing the defence from adducing, or commenting on, ever-expanding categories of relevant evidence — whether by legislation or by public shaming.

Scotland is ahead of us in this respect. Last year, the Supreme Court held that the combined effect of various pieces of Scottish anti-rape-defendant law, not so very different from our own, was in breach of the right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the ECHR: relevant evidence, helpful to the defence, was being excluded when it should be allowed. If we’re not there already, it is where we are heading. And it must be resisted — by practitioners, by the leaders of the Bar, by lawyers in Parliament, and by everyone who wants rapists convicted, and the innocent to walk free. Legislate in haste, repent at leisure.

And while, not least in view of the mix of verdicts that were all unanimous, there is no reason to doubt the guilt of Russell Brand where that has been found, my sometime editor, Kit Knightly, writes:

A major trial that has dominated the news cycle in the UK, has seen comedian/actor/alternate media guru Russell Brand convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault, and sentenced to ten years in prison. Similar to other major trials in the past, this is being used to push a meta narrative far broader than the specific crime in question. Lindsay Clancy’s (ongoing) trial is about postpartum depression and – eventually – empowering the state to seize your children. OJ Simpson’s trial became an exercise is stoking racial division. And Russell Brand’s trial is about normalising the UK’s increasingly tyrannical “justice system”.

For years, the British government has been planning “reforms” which completely undermine the most basic rights of the accused, rights designed to protect the individual from the state. We’ve covered it all in detail. The British state wants to remove the right to a jury trial, they want to coach witnesses, prevent defense lawyers from cross-examining witnesses or complainants, submit testimony in secret, cattle-tag released prisoners and limit their movements, incentivise allegations of domestic abuse. The right to a fair trial, the right to face your accuser, the right to a presumption of innocence. They are all under fire. These are protections dating back to Magna Carta, and they’re being thrown out to “protect victims” or “increase conviction rates”, empowering the state at the expense of the citizen. Russell Brand may or may not be guilty, he may or may not even be in prison, but his trial is now the pilot scheme for a new “justice system” that can be weaponised against anyone.

The Background

The story of how this trial came about is very odd – other people have done detailed write-ups on this history. To sum up, in 2022 The Times and Channel 4 started cooperating on what they termed “investigating” Russell Brand, resulting in a 2023 episode of the Dispatches documentary series called “Russell Brand – In Plain Sight”. Not one of the claims made in that documentary resulted in a criminal charge, rather, we are told, six anonymous women allegedly went to the police after seeing the documentary, and their claims resulted in criminal charges – three for rape and seven for sexual assault. 

Under British law, there is no such thing as a statute of limitations – Nullum tempus occurrit regi (time does not run against the crown). The charges were all from between 1999 and 2009, with one complainant claiming they weren’t sure if the alleged “sexual assault” occurred in 2004 or 2005. Also under British law, all six of these women are entitled to lifelong anonymity as “victims”, despite two of them being legally found to not be victims at all when the jury acquitted Brand of their charges. That’s the background. 

The Trial

The trial offers us our first high-profile view of a justice system in the midst of its ongoing “reform”. The complainants that testified did so behind screens, with their identities kept secret even from the jury. Some witnesses submitted pre-recorded video testimony, or testified over video link. This is a system notionally designed to “protect vulnerable witnesses” and prevent the “trauma” of “victims” being exposed to their abuser, but this is ludicrously prejudicial. 

The very fact the court officially states that the witnesses may be “vulnerable” and need protection from the accused presupposes that defendant is dangerous. The very fact the court officially states the “victims” may be “traumatised” by confronting their alleged rapist presupposes that a) they really were raped and b) the accused did the raping. The very description of them as “victims” – as opposed to the legally proper “complainant” – assumes the truth of the accusation and erodes all presumption of innocence.

In this particular trial there was allegedly no physical evidence produced – no DNA, no video or CCTV. No contemporaneous medical reports. No evidence any of the alleged crimes had even happened outside of recollections of events, all of which were between 17 and 27 years old. It was purely a case of “he said, she said”. Brand was found guilty on one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault, and acquitted of the other charges. He has been sentenced to over ten years in prison.

The Aftermath

As awful a display of “justice” as the trial was, it’s going to get worse. In the days following the conviction Mark Rowley, Chief of the Metropolitan Police, has claimed that some of the Brand’s defence bordered on “victim blaming”. Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Justice Secretary Alex Norris have echoed these sentiments, with vague statements made about “reforming” rape trials in the future. Burnham told the press we need to “make sure the woman does not feel she is on trial”. 

A lot of this discourse is centred around limiting how lawyers are allowed to defend their clients, specifically the use of so-called “rape myths”. “Rape Myths” are – according to Wikipedia – a list of “prejudicial, stereotyped, and false beliefs” about rape and sexual assault, allegedly including “women lie about rape” and “women falsely allege rape out of spite, guilt or regret”. Both of which are known to happen in some cases, and neither of which could ever be honestly described as a “myth”. 

Nevertheless, “Victims Commissioner” Claire Waxman has called for judges to explain these “rape myths” to juries in the future, with instructions to disregard them; or even have these so-called myths banned from discussion in the court entirely. Worse, Waxman advocates for punishing barristers who enter into a non-state approved defence: “I think there should be consequences for barristers who continue to bring this into the courtroom as a way that’s not evidence based.” 

To be clear, a defence barrister utilising “rape myths” includes asking “why didn’t you tell anyone for 20 years?” or “why did you keep seeing him afterwards?” or, “if you were being raped, why didn’t you scream or fight back?” Since “women lie about rape” is apparently one of these “myths”, the defence could be barred from any line of questioning that interrogates the credibility of the accuser (assuming the complainant has to answer questions at all, and isn’t just pre-recorded video tape). Barristers who do not follow those rules could face “disciplinary action”. This will extend to “specialised rape courts” and specially trained government-issued defence barristers with instructions about the kind of defence they are allowed to use. Essentially, once a woman claims she has been raped, it may become literally illegal to suggest she might be lying. 

And it’s not just the courts that we’re being told need “reform” or “regulation”. On Sunday, Russell Brand’s wife Laura uploaded a video to the couple’s shared YouTube channel in which she read out a letter she had received from her husband. This has been met with disgust across the political and media landscape, with many claiming it is illegal – which doesn’t appear to be true – or, more importantly, that it should be illegal. It’s a simple message claiming he is innocent, praising the staff of the prison, and asking for support for his family. Hardly controversial stuff. 

Nevertheless, Brand now faces being banned from communicating with his wife. And there are calls for her to be prosecuted (for what, they do not say) and the government has requested YouTube remove their channel. The story is that the internet, social media and “online broadcasting” are a “Wild West” in need of “regulation”. It’s worth noting that Just Stop Oil protestors were permitted to give interviews and write columns for The Guardian whilst in prison. Mia Latter – a woman who accuses Brand of orally raping her 20 years ago, but who was not involved in the trial – has “bravely” waived her anonymity to declare this shouldn’t be allowed. We “shouldn’t let these things be broadcast”? The “things” in question being protestations of innocence.  Are you seeing the agenda? Do you see how the system is shaping up?

  • Charges brought on (potentially decades-old) hearsay with no corroborating or contemporary evidence.
  • “Vulnerable” witnesses testifying via video link or pre-recorded testimony.
  • Witnesses/complainants testifying with the shield of anonymity and not subject to cross examination.
  • Specialised “rape courts” with specialised, government-trained “defense barristers” who have their hands tied.
  • Protesting your innocence after the fact is forbidden, because it “retraumatises the victims”, under penalty of increased incarceration or being denied contact with your family.
  • Shutting down independent sites or social media accounts which challenge the state’s version of events.

This isn’t about Brand, this is about normalising corrupt trials that assume guilt and treat protestations of innocence as a criminal act in and of themselves. And it’s going to get even worse. Andy Burnham has allegedly “scrapped” Keir Starmer’s plans to abolish trial by jury, but just like his “cancelling” digital ID, this is purely a delaying tactic. They are still coming for juries. What do you think he meant by “reforming” rape trials?

Then they’re going to incentivise guilty pleas with shorter sentences, and start cattle-tagging prisoners to limit their movements. They’re going to change the laws, not with the aim not of making the system fair, but purely to increase the conviction rate, regardless of guilt or evidence. We know this is the plan, because they keep saying so.

Russell Brand is easy to hate, and his behaviour easy to disapprove of, and that’s why he’s being thrown down on this barbed wire. They’re banking on people being afraid to appear to be “defending rapists”, resenting Brand’s politics, or delighting in the fall of a celebrity, and they are using this to cover massive authoritarian reforms of the “justice system”. But the next person put through this conviction-generating machinery won’t be a celebrity, and they won’t be able to afford high price lawyers or get support from their fans or coverage in the news, it will be just some ordinary citizen playing a fixed game.

And it’s very unlikely this will be limited to rape, either. Domestic abuse will come next. Hate speech, racism, misogyny, homophobia. “Denial” – of Covid, or climate change, or whatever else. The UK already arrests thousands of people a year for “harmful” social media posts, do you think this erosion of civil rights and due process won’t apply to them? Anything and everything is on the table, and with the current retrograde moral crusade sweeping the country, who knows what entirely normal behaviours may suddenly become “crimes” tomorrow. As I wrote last December:

It’s just a fact that whenever tyrannical legal reforms are mooted, it’s usually in the name of either rape, or child abuse, school shootings or domestic violence.

The why of this is fairly simple.

These are all crimes heinous enough that no one will want to be associated with them, or be seen to be defending the (alleged) perpetrators. The government leverages our disgust at this kind of crime in order to legislate permission to commit disgusting crimes of their own.

The significance of the Brand case isn’t Brand himself. Or how real or unreal his trial was. The significance is how these legal precedents and the potential changes in UK law that might be pushed through in this climate of hysteria will affect everyone else going forward. Because that’s the real purpose of show trials like this.

No comments:

Post a Comment