Wednesday, 21 October 2026

Hoyle’s War

My late grandmother, herself a former Member of the Legislative Council, absolutely loved Sir Lindsay Hoyle when he visited Saint Helena in February 2024. She was once required to leave the chamber because she had refused to withdraw her description of another member as “a liar”, so she would have known exactly what to do about the Ministers of whom Robert Hutton writes:

“It is shameful!” Lindsay Hoyle was furious. Spitting mad. Splenetic. His rag? It was lost. The minister’s arse? He was getting medieval on it. “It is appalling treatment!” The Speaker of the Commons likes to have his statements prepared in advance, and he was clutching pages of notes laying bare his immense displeasure, like an incensed driver who has finally got to the front of the queue to complain about an unjust parking fine. At any moment, it seemed he might reach down and start pulling supporting evidence from a Sainsbury’s Bag for Life.

The specific cause of his anger was the government’s screeching u-turn on using gas from the Jackdaw field in the North Sea. Not the decision itself –— others were dealing with that — but the fact that it had been reported everywhere before being announced in Parliament. Hoyle has for years been fighting to get ministers to stop doing this, without any noticeable effect. Now he was both mad as hell and not going to take it anymore. Making him madder was the fact that the Energy Secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh, had bravely decided to send an underling, Michael Shanks, to make the announcement and take the heat. She was in Aberdeen, speaking to broadcasters, although it’s entirely possible she could still hear Hoyle at that distance.

“I’m sorry that Sky News is more important, rather than the members,” the Speaker said, gesturing around him. Was his point undermined by the sight of MPs fleeing in search of lunch? Not a bit of it. “This issue has been of great interest to the House!” That is certainly true. It’s a bruise that the Conservatives have been punching for months, aware that Fahnbulleh’s predecessor, Ed Miliband, didn’t want to grant the license and that Keir Starmer didn’t know what he wanted. Wednesday’s announcement can be seen as a basic marker of competence by Andy Burnham’s administration. Whatever the merits of the argument, dragging it out was only hurting.

The prime minister had earlier tried to make the best of the u-turn. Kemi Badenoch had arrived triumphant, ever more certain that everything that happens is evidence of her brilliance. “The Conservatives first approved Jackdaw in 2022!” she announced. That gave Burnham an opening: “We have made a decision that her government messed up. There was a delay because they didn’t do the process properly.”

The Tory leader sneered at this as Starmerism redux, and who can doubt that a Badenoch administration would indeed charge around announcing things before seeing them overturned in the courts? Badenoch’s big advantage was that Burnham had, when all was said and done, accepted her arguments. “The gas would still be needed,” he told the Greens’ Ellie Chowns, while the Tory frontbench waved their arms to point out that this was what they’d been saying for months. “It would just be imported from somewhere else.” 

Both leaders are still feeling each other out, trying to work out how to characterise the other. The Tory leader had a reply when Burham trumpeted his social care policy as an example of a big decision: “Talking about it is not making a decision.” Meanwhile, after getting into trouble for speaking off the cuff in the past, the prime minister was more careful this week, keeping his folder of notes open to remind him of prepared lines and facts and figures. He’s developed a tactic of looking for areas where he can agree with Badenoch, emphasising his essential congeniality. Only in his final question did he refer to Liz Truss’s forthcoming book about how she was done over by a conspiracy involving the Bank of England, the Freemasons and aliens from the planet Mars. 

Speaking of people who don’t know when to stay quiet, at much the same time, Reform’s Zia Yusuf released a video rant showing how intensely unconcerned the party is by recent reporting of the views of its members. It’s best summarised as “You can’t expose us, we’re exposing YOU!” After threats to set the police on ITV, and complaints about the hurt feelings of Reform’s loyal army of snowflakes, it finished with a promise to blow the party’s donor bounty on court cases against any journalist who makes Yusuf cry. It’s highly entertaining, and I recommend it to anyone who needs cheering up. Perhaps the Speaker should take a look. He was still fuming when we left him, seconds away from turning green and smashing up the chamber. “It is simply not good enough!” he stormed. “I thought this was a new beginning!” It may be, but nothing will stop governments from trailing announcements to the press. We’ll be seeing Angry Hoyle again.

2 comments:

  1. The briefcases think that Hoyle should move with the times.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, of course they do. But he won't. Nor should he.

      Delete