Jamie Grierson writes:
Theresa May risks
“turning the clock back 140 years” with discredited plans for police and crime commissioners
(PCCs) to take over fire authorities, the head of the firefighters’ union has
warned.
Matt Wrack, general secretary of
the Fire Brigades Union (FBU), said May’s proposals to give PCCs
responsibilities for fire and rescue had not been tested and had no support
from either of the emergency services involved.
The home secretary has previously
said allowing PCCs to take over fire and rescue authorities would “provide
direct, democratic accountability in fire as we now have in policing”.
Speaking on the Today programme
on BBC Radio 4, Wrack said: “I think the claim by Theresa May that this
improves local accountability is just nonsense.
“The police and crime
commissioners, as everyone knows, were elected on a local turnout of about 15%
that makes them less democratic than local councils, which are generally
currently what runs the fire and rescue service across the UK so that claim is
completely unsustainable.”
Wrack said a model of combining
police and fire services had already been attempted in Britain in 1870 and was
discredited.
“We had police-fire services in
Britain – they were discredited from about 1870 so Theresa May plans to clock
back about 140 years in this.
“The models around the world don’t reflect what’s
being proposed here. This model hasn’t been tested. The consultation has been
rushed; there’s no evidence been produced.
“There’s no support for it in
fire, there’s no support for it in the police, apart from one or two police and
crime commissioners.”
Wrack’s comments come after his
union posted strong criticism of the proposals on its website.
A statement said:
“Enabling PCCs
to govern fire and rescue services will neither deliver economic, efficient or
effective emergency services nor optimise public safety.
“On the contrary, these
proposals threaten to damage the well-earned trust of the public in
firefighters, hamper innovation and will lead to the fragmentation of emergency
services delivery across the UK.”
PCCs “do not bring any skills or expertise” to the
service and some have an “unfortunate record for ill-judged interference in
operational matters”, it added.
May said fire services have poor
procurement, IT systems and buildings management.
“I look at the fire and
rescue service and I see the need for many of the same reforms that I started
in policing five years ago: better local accountability, more transparency and
a relentless focus on efficiency,” May said.
“So, while I continue to finish
the job of reform in policing, I am also determined to properly kick start the
job of reform in fire.”
The home secretary added:
“I am
struck by the fact the fire and rescue service doesn’t have an independent
inspectorate and does not routinely publish data on performance. Local people
need these things to hold their local public services to account.
“And from my experience fire has
the same problems as policing in terms of poor procurement, ICT and management
of buildings. I’d like to bring the same collaborative approach we’re seeing in
policing to fire services, too.
All three emergency services will
be forced to look at ways to work together to improve efficiency, including
through sharing administration systems to cut costs.
No comments:
Post a Comment