Sunday 7 June 2009

Referendum Results

Probably by the time that you read this, all seven will be in.

First, the referendum in Scotland (like Wales or Northern Ireland a single entity for European but no other electoral purposes) on the centrality of the constitutional question to political discourse there. If the SNP takes three of the six seats, then the fissure in Scottish political opinion really is on that question, so that that discourse must continue to be defined and conducted accordingly. But if no third seat is picked up by the SNP, then such is manifestly not the case, and the organisation of Scottish politics as if it were must cease forthwith.

Secondly, the referendum in Scotland on the (always exaggerated) importance of the Labour Party there. If Labour holds its second seat, then it will still deserve to be treated as more important than the Tories or the Lib Dems. But if it does not, then it no longer will.

Thirdly, the referendum in Northern Ireland on the UUP’s putative takeover by the Tories. If the UUP holds its seat, then, even if only by means of second preference votes, the Unionist community will have blessed that marriage. But if it does not, then that marriage will be positively cursed. A blessing, with everything that would follow from it, would make unanswerable both the moral and the electoral case for Labour (or its successors) and the Lib Dems (or their successors) to organise in Northern Ireland.

Fourthly, the referendum in Northern Ireland on, frankly, the continued existence of the SDLP. No one doubts that there will be enough votes to elect a Sinn Féin MEP. This being STV, there ought therefore to be enough second preference votes, at least, for the SDLP either to secure someone’s election or to run the UUP a very, very close fourth indeed. If there are not, then what is any longer the purpose of the SDLP? What is it for? But it never does quite as badly as predicted. So this is certainly one to watch.

Fifthly, the referendum on the continued existence of the BNP. If, even under these circumstances and using this electoral system, it cannot elect anyone at all, then it is finished.

Sixthly, the referendum on the Political and Media Classes’ attitude to their fellow-citizens. If the BNP is not successful, then the knuckle-dragging proles do not exist in any great numbers (there is no suggestion that they do not exist at all), and we as a people do not need to be lorded over by our betters, but rather to govern ourselves in and through our genuinely elected and accountable representatives at every level. This is most especially a referendum on the true character of the white working class, and thus on how that class deserves to be treated economically, socially, culturally and politically.

And seventhly, the referendum on the “big” three political parties, with their lavish State funding, their privileged media access, and all the rest of it. In particular, if Labour and the Tories do not better their combined forty-two per cent of the eligible vote (not just the votes cast, but the votes that could have been cast) at the last General Election, then the game really is over once and for all.

8 comments:

  1. Lots of ifs and buts in there David. But I think your right If you thought about it long enough. :-))

    Good feeling for the Nats tonight!! :-))

    ReplyDelete
  2. Its funny how I've never seen these referendums anywhere else. Its good of you to set out these tests for all our elected politicians, and I only hope they can live up to your high standards, as a representative of the rule making class.

    ReplyDelete
  3. With Norn Iron having three seats the same as the North East of England.....and deliberately arranged so that no one community can take all seats (always being PR)...I still suspect SDLP will get a very large vote.
    Elections are generally speaking about "what it says on the tin".

    With SDLP reconciled to the fact that in this election at least it will not outvote Sinn Féin-IRA, the object of the exercise is probably to build Maginness profile.
    Chances are that he will seek the nomination of the winnable seat of South Down at Westminster when Eddie McGrady steps down.
    He would make a better candidate than Margaret Ritchie, McGradys long time office manager. She is currently the only SDLP member in the Govt.
    So 2010 should be a run off between Ritchie and Caitriona Ruane. See the ark website for 2007 Assembly and 2005 Westminster stats.
    For all Ritchies undoubted sincerity she is a lightweight and Magennis would be a much better standard bearer for "Constitutional nationalism".

    Fourth place would be a good result for SDLP.
    Interestingly I have posted the NI turnouts figures for the Euro election in my own blog.
    Highest seven turnouts in SDLP and SF-IRA strongholds
    Indicates high Nat/Republican turn out but not enuff to give SDLP second seat.

    I have to say that it appears to me that the English shire elections have distorted the turnout in Tory favour

    ReplyDelete
  4. What about the referendum on whether anyone thinks that "No2EU - Yes2Democracy" is a worthwhile organisation?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm sorry it didn't go well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It could hardly have gone better.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I don't know. I think you might be one of those people who always sees things the way you want them to be.

    That might be a pleasant trait to have, I suppose.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't think too many readers of this blog will have marked me down as that!

    ReplyDelete