"BritCard"? How the years roll back, and not in a good way. Tony Blair's computerisation of the NHS was the biggest civilian IT project ever. 23 years later, there is still no sign of it. Set that alongside the cyberattack on Jaguar Land Rover. Then ponder the digital ID that was proposed in June by Morgan McSweeney's Labour Together, hence the hideously Noughties name. Announcing it now to deflect attention from the undeclared £700,000 displays undeniable self-belief.
Identity cards have always been a New Labour obsession to rank with NHS privatisation, although that was never to be attempted except in England, with the NHS recognised as the strongest argument for the Union in the other three parts of the United Kingdom. This Government is so bad at politics that it intends to impose the BritCard from West Glamorgan, to West Lothian, to West Belfast. There may be riots in Scotland. There may be worse than that across the Irish Sea.
Although the Coalition discontinued Blair's attempt at this, it had in fact become government policy under John Major and Michael Howard. William Hague speaks for the grandees when he enthusiastically commends it today. Accordingly, Kemi Badenoch sits on the fence, while Chris Philp is positively enthusiastic, as have been several people who were now leading members of Reform UK. Ann Widdecombe was calling for this only three months ago, on exactly the grounds that Keir Starmer now purported to advocate it.
Everyone on that march on 13 September put themselves on Palantir's facial recognition system. The shock troops of the resistance need to come from elsewhere. My old friend Dr Dave Smith is now applying for a judicial review of the failure to call him to give oral evidence to the spycops inquiry. If that scandal received anything like the coverage that it deserved, then digital ID would have public approval below 10 per cent. Dave's Blacklist Support Group is old school trade unionism, crossing over as that does with the justice campaigns around Shrewsbury, Clay Cross, the Battle of the Beanfield, Hillsborough, Orgreave, Grenfell Tower, the Windrush scandal, the Post Office scandal, the contaminated blood scandal, the WASPI women, the wrongfully imprisoned, the nuclear test veterans, and very many more.
A start has been made by Dave's union and mine, Unite, which has declined to nominate either candidate for Deputy Leader of the Labour Party. One of them is still a member of this Cabinet, the other said that the Winter Fuel Payment had to be withdrawn to prevent a run on the pound. They are both in favour of the digital ID that would be delivered by the Tony Blair Institute while Blair himself was spending at least five years heading "the Gaza International Transitional Authority". I first told you on 13 November 2023 that Blair was being lined up to be Viceroy of Gaza, now on behalf of a State that would by then have recognised the Falkland Islands as part of Argentina.
No change there, of course, since Israel armed Argentina during the Falklands War, with Menachem Begin seeing that as revenge. Israel is much closer to Javier Milei than even to Starmer, while Liz Truss has said that she would have endorsed Milei as a candidate for Leader of the Conservative Party. His Argentina is the latest Promised Land of the British Right, which always needs a Fatherland somewhere away from the NHS. The real sport will be over Israel's attitude to the sovereignty of Gibraltar, since Spain has also recognised Palestine. Will Gibraltarians be issued with Blair's BritCards while he ran Gaza on behalf of a foreign power that thought that they should not be British? Very possibly. Will Falkland Islanders be in that position? Without doubt. Unless we had stopped this whole scheme in its tracks.
Zara Sultana has joined Britain’s poll-leading party Reform UK in condemning ID cards. Annoying as it is to have that clown on our side on any issue, the more the merrier on this.
ReplyDeleteShe said it before them. Although Jeremy Corbyn said it before her.
DeleteThen Shadow Home Secretary David Davis killed off ID cards under Tony Blair. Nigel Farage and Zia Yusuf confirm Britain’s poll-leading party Reform UK will lead the opposition this time.
ReplyDeleteNot even Davis himself would claim that. It did in fact pass. But the Coalition, because it was the Coalition, repealed it before it could be properly implemented.
DeleteOpposing Big State control and surveillance is a no-brainer for a rightwing populist party so no surprise Reform is leading the opposition to this. Nigel Farage writes: “ I am firmly opposed to Keir Starmer’s digital ID cards. It will make no difference to illegal immigration, but it will be used to control and penalise the rest of us. The state should never have this much power.”
ReplyDeleteWith out announcement that we’ll scrap the indefinite leave to remain for immigrants and all benefits will be restricted to British citizens under a Reform government, no wonder Sky’s mega poll has Farage on course to be PM.
https://news.sky.com/story/nigel-farage-on-course-to-be-next-prime-minister-mega-poll-projects-13438143
More joy in Heaven. But a lot of leading Reform figures were saying the opposite into the recent past. When this was last attempted, then it was the TUC that resolved to oppose ID cards "with every means at its disposal". Note that this latest announcement has had to be made only after this year's Congress had safely gone home.
DeleteEvery leading Reform figure from Nigel Farage to Zia Yusuf has consistently opposed ID cards and were leading the opposition now. As a huge expansion of state power, mandatory ID cards are natural for a Labour government but anathema to any rightwing movement.
ReplyDeleteEvery leading Reform figure from Nigel Farage to Zia Yusuf has consistently opposed ID cards
DeleteThat simply is not true. I am glad that they are here now. But quite a few of them have taken the scenic root. They have carried over the long Tory split on this, which is still there.
Diane Abbott, Katy Clark, Frank Cook, Jeremy Corbyn, Mark Fisher, Paul Flynn, George Galloway, Kate Hoey, Kelvin Hopkins, Lynne Jones, Bob Marshall-Andrews, John McDonnell, Linda Riordan, Clare Short, Alan Simpson, John Smith, Bob Wareing and Mike Wood all voted against Tony Blair's Identity Cards Bill. So did all the Lib Dems and Nationalists plus the DUP and Richard Taylor. No Tory did but one of several abstainers was Ann Widdecombe.
ReplyDeleteEven the reasoned amendment at Second Reading was tabled by Lynne Jones, so there cannot have been an Official Opposition one to call. There were only 10 Conservative votes against Second Reading, and only 11 at Third Reading, joining 19 Labour rebels.
DeleteLed as it was by Michael Howard, the Conservative Party was avowedly in favour of the principle, to which it is still not explicitly opposed. And Reform is full of Conservatives from 20 years ago, if not a great deal more recently. Neither party's core vote or activist base is solidly against this. But the Left is. As with the anti-war movement, the leadership must come from us.
Sarah Pochin, so obviously no earlier than 24 March 2025: https://x.com/reformexposed/status/1971550339435540724
ReplyDeleteMartin Daubney, right in the middle of the lockdowns: https://x.com/trevhewsongy/status/1971592594619834444/photo/1
Darren Grimes, less than three years ago: https://x.com/trevhewsongy/status/1971592594619834444/photo/2
And many more.
I am very glad that they have changed their minds. But they have. And not everyone around or behind them has.
DeleteReform are opportunists on this or they've realised they're not Tories any more so not in the club.
ReplyDeleteBoth of those things are true, but they will do for now. All hands to the pumps.
DeleteNigel Farage has always opposed national ID cards. Find me a single quote to the contrary. Even the Tories scrapped Labour’s ID cards bill as soon as they got in government in 2010.
ReplyDeleteIt was the Lib Dems who insisted on that. They had a wobble on it this week, but they are back on side now. David Cameron and George Osborne were protégés of Michael Howard. Kemi Badenoch still will not say that she is opposed to the principle, while Chris Philp is actively in favour. Nigel Farage, meanwhile, is surrounded by recent entrants from that milieu.
DeleteThe Tories were planning this only last month: https://x.com/Adrian_Hilton/status/1971836765053837730/photo/1
ReplyDeleteIndeed. They secured £400 million towards it in 2021. Their name for it was One Login. Had they won last year, then we would have had it this year or next.
DeleteBen Wallace supporting digital ID, as you say the grandees: https://archive.ph/VEMHc
ReplyDeleteAnd in the Telegraph, too. That has only ever been against this under Labour Governments, and apparently now no longer even that.
Delete