Friday, 7 December 2012

Marriage Guidance

Now that the debate on marriage is open, let us make the most of it. Any marrying couple should be entitled to register their marriage as bound by the law prior to 1969 with regard to grounds and procedures for divorce, and any religious organisation should be enabled to specify that any marriage which it conducted should be so bound, requiring it to counsel couples accordingly.

Statute should specify that the Church of England be such a body unless the General Synod specifically resolved the contrary by a two-thirds majority in all three Houses, with something similar for the Methodist and United Reformed Churches, which also exist pursuant to Acts of Parliament, as well as by amendment to the legislation relating to the restoration of the Catholic hierarchy. Entitlement upon divorce should be fixed by Statute at one per cent of the other party’s estate for each year of marriage, up to fifty per cent, with no entitlement for the petitioning party unless the other party’s fault be proved.

That would be a start, anyway. The marital union of one man and one woman is a public good uniquely and in itself, and the taxation system, among so very many other instruments of public policy, ought to recognise that fact. It ought to recognise marriage as a unique public good, to which civil partnerships (which, never having needed to be consummated, ought not to be confined to unrelated same-sex couples) are not comparable. And it ought to recognise marriage as a public good in itself, whether or not there are children, a related but different public good of which other forms of recognition rightly exist.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Didn't you say Labour wouldn't whip their MPs on this issue. That's not what the BBC are reporting.....

David Lindsay said...

I can tell you with absolute certainty that that is the case. I have just had a phone call (how they have my mobile number, I have no idea) asking me to make that clear, apparently because my readers may be few, but they are all the right people to whom this point needs to be made. I am more than happy to do so.

Anonymous said...

That's really impressive. Who was the phone call from?

David Lindsay said...

I'm not going to tell you.

Anonymous said...

Who asks a question like that?

David Lindsay said...

On topic, please.