Monday, 30 November 2009

Votes For Prisoners?

No, Marcel Berlins. A thousand times, no.

There could not be a clearer example of why no ruling of, among other things, the ECHR should have any effect in this country unless or until confirmed by resolution of the House of Commons.

How many European countries do let prisoners vote? Very, very few, I'd bet.

Anyway, if you want votes for prisoners, then vote Lib Dem. If you don't, then don't.

27 comments:

Slow said...

"How many European countries do let prisoners vote? Very, very few, I'd bet."

In the EU, prisoners are allowed to vote in France, the Netherlands, Poland, Denmark, Sweden, the Czech Republic and Romania. In Germany, they can vote unless convicted of electoral fraud and crimes undermining the "democratic order". In the Republic of Ireland, prisoners are allowed to vote but until recently were effectively barred because they could not get to a polling station - since 2006, they have been allowed a postal vote. Non-EU countries which allow prisoners to vote include Australia, Canada, Norway, Peru, Serbia, Japan, Israel and Kenya.

David Lindsay said...

So that's seven and bit out of 27 in the EU.

And eight out of however many in the rest of the world.

Timothy said...

There are no legal restrictions on prisoners voting in 18 European countries. Eight do impose restrictions - most of these are in Eastern Europe and the former USSR.

David Lindsay said...

Make your minds up.

And I thought we now liked "Eastern Europe and the former USSR"? In which, are you including Germany for this purpose?

Salome said...

"Slow" and "Timothy" haven't actually contradicted each other, although they may be working from different sources - it doesn't look to me like they're trying to have a fight; I think they're being helpful, since you asked a question and they both answered it. I have no idea whether or not they like Eastern Europe and the former USSR, but it's pretty irrelevant to your factual question about which EU countries let prisoners vote. I'd have thought Germany does count as "Eastern Europe" for these purposes - if "Slow" is correct, then it does have some restrictions on prisoners voting.

David Lindsay said...

As should we.

A total restriction, in fact.

So don't vote Lib Dem.

Abe said...

What's "like" got to do with it? Most of: Armenia; Bulgaria; the Czech Republic; Estonia; Hungary; Luxemburg; Romania and Russia are in Eastern Europe and the USSR, and these are the EU countries (other than the UK) which ban prisoners from voting.

In other words, 18 of the 27 EU states have no ban on prisoner voting. You lose your bet. But I wouldn't worry - we all make mistakes from time to time.

David Lindsay said...

What, like suggesting that Armenia and Russia are in the EU?

Abe said...

Exactly. Dumb error, my mistake.

Now it's your turn...

Awaywego said...

Abe is confused - I think he means Council of Europe, not European Union.

David Lindsay said...

Well, Abe, do you?

Petey said...

Abe got something wrong, you got something wrong. Call it quits.

Rob said...

"Quits" is not a David Lindsay word.

Mandy said...

He's a changer-of-the-subject, not a quitter.

Tom said...

Seriously Mandy, he has been known to bear a grudge.

Rob said...

Just a bit Tom, just a bit.

David Lindsay said...

On-topic, please.

Mandy said...

See what I mean?

David Lindsay said...

I make no apology for changing it back to the topic.

Anonymous said...

The NuLabs in all parties are on here in force I see. Only their fellow shysters, junkies and nonces would still vote for them so they have to be given a vote from behind bars.

David Lindsay said...

"Only their fellow shysters, junkies and nonces would still vote for them", assuming that the rest of us give ourselves any alternative.

Remember, if you vote for any of them, then this is what you are voting for: dirty money, drugs effectively legalised, the age of consent effectively lowered to 13 or below, polling stations in prisons, and the final authority of foreign courts (or of a nominally domestic court deferring thereto and detached from a parliamentary process in relation to which it is "Supreme").

So don't vote for any of them.

Make alternative arrangements.

Q said...

All the critical comments have been posted from prison. I guarantee it.

David Lindsay said...

Sadly, these are the people who should be rather than the people who are. They do far more damage than the people who are, who would themselves have done far less damage, and who would be far less numerous, without them.

Anonymous said...

You've criticized the Afghan war, the screeching for war against Iran, and the Demjanjuk show trial. So this harassment is only to be expected.

Brian said...

And you will insist that they are all old Commies and Trots. No wonder they hate you quite so much, what with that and the opposition to drugs, child sex and funny money.

Tim said...

Your real crime is to be about to give an electoral choice to the people they think are their serfs who pay tribute at the ballot box.

Rose said...

Not just that, Tim, he stands in the way of putting in a supporter of partial birth abortion as all AWS candidates for Labour have to be and all new LD have had to be since some time in the 90s.